I have found that the powders which work for a cartridge and bullet weight in a 26 inch barrel work best in a 20-inch barrel as well.
For example, my .270 and 7x64 Mannlichers do best with the same H4831 recipes which work in my 22-inch .270 Remington 700, 24-inch .270 Mauser, and my 23.6 inch Steyr Pro Hunter 7x64. My .270 Mannlicher shows only 50 fps less than my 24-inch Mauser with the same 130-gr and 150-gr ammunition.
Likewise, the best loads for my 22-inch .30-06 rifles are also best in my 26-inch Browning B78 - they just fly faster.60
There was a discussion of this for the 6.5x55mm a few years ago, right after I joined. The OP had a 20-inch carbine, and was wondering about a faster powder. He found that N160 gave the top accuracy and velocity.
There are just other factors at play: chamber dimensions, brass, primers, 1/1,000 inch tighter bore, etc.
For example, my .270 and 7x64 Mannlichers do best with the same H4831 recipes which work in my 22-inch .270 Remington 700, 24-inch .270 Mauser, and my 23.6 inch Steyr Pro Hunter 7x64. My .270 Mannlicher shows only 50 fps less than my 24-inch Mauser with the same 130-gr and 150-gr ammunition.
Likewise, the best loads for my 22-inch .30-06 rifles are also best in my 26-inch Browning B78 - they just fly faster.60
There was a discussion of this for the 6.5x55mm a few years ago, right after I joined. The OP had a 20-inch carbine, and was wondering about a faster powder. He found that N160 gave the top accuracy and velocity.
There are just other factors at play: chamber dimensions, brass, primers, 1/1,000 inch tighter bore, etc.