I lost mine in October ‘21.
He was bloody brilliant, the dog of a lifetime. I taught him nothing other than to walk to heel and stop & stay. The rest was all instinct, pointing fur & feather, tracking, he just got on with it as if he knew what he was doing. Brilliant in the home, a bit needy but that was fine.
When I had to replace him I thought hard about what I didn’t like. There wasn’t a lot, but he was a bit soft, hated rain and didn’t cope well with the cold. He was also very nervous around strange people and dogs which came out as mild aggression that never resulted in a problem but he did scare the **** out of people on a regular basis.
I didn’t want another HWV as I didn’t want to compare another dog to Bear, so I looked for something that was essentially very similar but would be more hardy and more confident. I got a GWP.
He’s 17 months now. Jury still out. I definitely got all I asked for, he’s very hardy and very confident, I just hadn’t banked on the incredible prey drive that comes with it. He’s been stalking at heel since about 9 months. We’ve shot 30 odd deer together. He is indicating deer well and tracking very well. We are up to the moors this spring for counting and pointer training and if that goes to plan we will be shooting grouse over him this season. But he is bloody turbo charged and you have to be on him the whole time. If I can tame the beast he will be a better dog than the HWV, but it will have been a lot tougher getting there.
So to my mind, whilst the GWP can potentially be a better dog the HWV will get to 90% with a lot less stress and training. I’m young enough (just) to be very happy with my choice and the challenge, but if I was 10 years older or didn’t have the hours to put in I would go for another HWV without hesitation.
Hope that helps.