Which Knife?

stevec

Well-Known Member
I am thinking of getting a new knife in the next few months. Big birthday coming up, but I still don't want to be silly, just something basic and good quality.

I currently have one of these:

1737324913407.webp

A Svord Drop point hunter. It was my only knife for many years. I like it, but I have found that the drop point blunts very quickly gralloching deer (cutting through hair) and the lack of a point at the end means it isn't ideal for gutting fish. I suppose I have a sentimental attachment to it.

I also have one of these:

1737325078010.webp
A Mora Companion Carbon. I find the point on the end easier to work with. It is about 2 cm shorter an a lot lighter. I really like it, however, i have a couple of concerns - I have an acquaintance who runs bushcraft course and they use these knives and he tells me they are prone to snapping at the tang. He has seen it happen several times (mainly in extreme temperatures, but once in the UK) and his advice was that the tang on the Svord knives is so much better and more reliable. Also, I am concerned that some insect repellants will dissolve the plastic handle.

A friend is trying to pursue me to go on a trip with him to a remote area of the Erongo mountains in Namibia inaccessible with vehicles, that involves trekking in, camping and wearing a lot of Deet. Does anyone have any suggestions for a simple, lightweight and tough knife that can cope with fishing, gralloching and other camping type uses that can be relied upon in a remote area where equipment needs to be kept to a minimum?

I had wondered about a Lion Steel Ago - looks like a very thin blade and I don't know how micara copes with Deet:
1737325922470.webp
A Puma Hunter's Pal - might not be ideal for fish though:

1737326005505.webp
 

Attachments

  • 1737325983667.webp
    1737325983667.webp
    14.5 KB · Views: 4
Mora Classic 2F - I am sure this would do the job 90% of the time, but there is still a risk of the tang snapping:

1737326234395.webp
 
So many choices! What’s your budget? For a production fixed I like ESEE as well as MORA for cheaper larder work. Benchmade ans Spyderco make some fantastic blades. I tend to buy customs these days, Stuart Mitchell makes some lovely ones if you can stretch to that.
 
I will have a look at the above.

Ideally less than £150. I think the Mora Classic 2F would do the job fine, I just wouldn't it snapping in the middle of nowhere.

Another option would be to get a custom knife maker to make a Mora Companion shaped knife but with a full tang. I suspect that would be expensive.
 
Oh man… the choices!

My suggestions for a sub £150 that you’d really be happy to use in the long term:

Casstrom Woodsman. Best factory knife I’ve owned. Superb bushcraft knife. Very easy to sharpen. Sheath comes with a firesteel loop. I’ve used one to gralloch and ‘field larder’ a cow (Highland x Limousin bull). Can be had for £149.

Brisa Trapper 95. Another really excellent general use knife. Can be had with either a Scandi grind or full flat grind. Get full flat if the primary use will be hunting and meat processing. Get the Scandi if it’s mainly bushcraft. Can be had for around £135.

TBS Lynx or Boar. TBS make a range of ‘in house’ knives to very high standards for the price. They’re aimed at the Bushcraft market, but are good general use knives. They’re aimed come with a variety of sheaths, from simple pouches to bells and whistles with attachments for firesteel and sharpeners. They look good and feel very good in the hand. The steel is rather soft - I think possibly both to keep costs down and to make sharpening easy. But they’re great beginner knives for very reasonable prices.

Fallkiven F1. A reliable workhorse that everyone should try once! I had one for about 12 years, and used it on hundreds of deer. Indestructible and has the grippiest handle of them all. However is very much a tool, and I never really loved it. It also takes some getting used to to sharpen properly - not one to easily do in the field. Possibly also know over the £150 mark.

Finally, you could probably get a @Stuart Mitchell for under £150 if you went for one of his bare-bones P90 or P120 ultralights. He is a wizard and an absolute gentleman who produces the most fantastically usable and esthetically pleasing knives imaginable.
 
I am thinking of getting a new knife in the next few months. Big birthday coming up, but I still don't want to be silly, just something basic and good quality.

I currently have one of these:

View attachment 402436

A Svord Drop point hunter. It was my only knife for many years. I like it, but I have found that the drop point blunts very quickly gralloching deer (cutting through hair) and the lack of a point at the end means it isn't ideal for gutting fish. I suppose I have a sentimental attachment to it.

I also have one of these:

View attachment 402437
A Mora Companion Carbon. I find the point on the end easier to work with. It is about 2 cm shorter an a lot lighter. I really like it, however, i have a couple of concerns - I have an acquaintance who runs bushcraft course and they use these knives and he tells me they are prone to snapping at the tang. He has seen it happen several times (mainly in extreme temperatures, but once in the UK) and his advice was that the tang on the Svord knives is so much better and more reliable. Also, I am concerned that some insect repellants will dissolve the plastic handle.

A friend is trying to pursue me to go on a trip with him to a remote area of the Erongo mountains in Namibia inaccessible with vehicles, that involves trekking in, camping and wearing a lot of Deet. Does anyone have any suggestions for a simple, lightweight and tough knife that can cope with fishing, gralloching and other camping type uses that can be relied upon in a remote area where equipment needs to be kept to a minimum?

I had wondered about a Lion Steel Ago - looks like a very thin blade and I don't know how micara copes with Deet:
View attachment 402439
A Puma Hunter's Pal - might not be ideal for fish though:

View attachment 402441
In fact - here you go:

 
I have found the Marttiini Lumberjack:

1737409692788.webp
Similar price to a basic mora, no plastic and nice leather sheath. I think I might have a go with that.
 
Fallkiven F1. A reliable workhorse that everyone should try once! I had one for about 12 years, and used it on hundreds of deer. Indestructible and has the grippiest handle of them all. However is very much a tool, and I never really loved it. It also takes some getting used to to sharpen properly - not one to easily do in the field. Possibly also know over the £150 mark.
£154 at Hennie Haynes
 
Back
Top