Page 1 of 11 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 106

Thread: Deer dog standard of training for Lamping contractors

  1. #1

    Deer dog standard of training for Lamping contractors

    I know this has been done before but it's a pertinent question with the recent recommendations in the SNH review of deer authorisations.
    http://www.snh.gov.uk/protecting-sco...utory-returns/

    The review is suggesting that deer dogs are trained to a set standard and that some people have suggested that the standard could be based on continental models of training/testing.
    This doesn't really fit for me, I was under the impression that these dedicated tracking dogs don't work in the dark? That's not going to be much use for a Lamping dog? Is there a European method that fits our needs in this country? What are folks opinions of how SNH should address the need for standardised training/testing for dogs?
    The more I learn about people, the more I like my dog.

  2. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by Shabz View Post
    I know this has been done before but it's a pertinent question with the recent recommendations in the SNH review of deer authorisations.
    http://www.snh.gov.uk/protecting-sco...utory-returns/

    The review is suggesting that deer dogs are trained to a set standard and that some people have suggested that the standard could be based on continental models of training/testing.
    This doesn't really fit for me, I was under the impression that these dedicated tracking dogs don't work in the dark? That's not going to be much use for a Lamping dog? Is there a European method that fits our needs in this country? What are folks opinions of how SNH should address the need for standardised training/testing for dogs?
    I'd agree. I'm sure that European dogs could work in the dark, and they are very effective, but why restrict to one standard? Lamping dogs, I would imagine would rapidly deployed for follow up on a relatively hot scent.

    Also in the dark, it would be more difficult to locate the point of shot - wouldn't you want a dog (GWP of course ;-) ) that you could cast out and let it get on with it?

    Siggy.

  3. #3
    I think that they would find it very difficult to implement this.

  4. #4
    Are u not already meant to have a 'trained deer dog' just that they never set a standard.

    I don't think ur ever going to have a dog that tracks in the dark, not because the dog can't do it, would make no odds to the dog but because the human isn't capable off following safely or reading the dog.

    Ur talking about european standards, but if u look at any of the threads or posts by either the UKSHA or UKDTR (who i'm sure will be along to correct me if i'm wrong)
    But everything starts from the shot site, how/where deer is hit, if u can't establish that u probably wouldn't track, plus most advocate a decent time delay (injury dependent) so realistically ur looking at marking the position u shot from, line of shot and where u think u hit it and coming back the next morning to track.
    The simple fact is in most cases u won't be able to see the shot sight well enough in the dark, even if u can and u decide to track will be very hard to see/read ur dog even on its line in the dark so u'll have no idea wot its indicating or if it has veered off track.
    There is also some fairly big health and safety concerns too, esp if shooting over restock sites, can be a pita in daylight never mind in darkness.

    There probably should be more dogs trained to a higher standard, u could probably argue that a stalkers own dog would not really need to be trained to a 24 hr standard as he will be able to take it out next morning, so realistically a 12hr track should be good enough.

    Sort of casting a dog out and letting it get on with it is the very oppisate of wot ur properly trained deer dogs do

    But really the whole deer dog thing has came on a long way in a relatively short space of time,
    And simple fact is it will take years to implement as generally ur only replacing a dog every 7-8 yrs so u can't just spring it on stalkers, even if they bought a new pup for the law it will take a year or so to get it up to standard

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by countrryboy View Post
    Are u not already meant to have a 'trained deer dog' just that they never set a standard.

    I don't think ur ever going to have a dog that tracks in the dark, not because the dog can't do it, would make no odds to the dog but because the human isn't capable off following safely or reading the dog.

    Ur talking about european standards, but if u look at any of the threads or posts by either the UKSHA or UKDTR (who i'm sure will be along to correct me if i'm wrong)
    But everything starts from the shot site, how/where deer is hit, if u can't establish that u probably wouldn't track, plus most advocate a decent time delay (injury dependent) so realistically ur looking at marking the position u shot from, line of shot and where u think u hit it and coming back the next morning to track.
    The simple fact is in most cases u won't be able to see the shot sight well enough in the dark, even if u can and u decide to track will be very hard to see/read ur dog even on its line in the dark so u'll have no idea wot its indicating or if it has veered off track.
    There is also some fairly big health and safety concerns too, esp if shooting over restock sites, can be a pita in daylight never mind in darkness.

    There probably should be more dogs trained to a higher standard, u could probably argue that a stalkers own dog would not really need to be trained to a 24 hr standard as he will be able to take it out next morning, so realistically a 12hr track should be good enough.

    Sort of casting a dog out and letting it get on with it is the very oppisate of wot ur properly trained deer dogs do

    But really the whole deer dog thing has came on a long way in a relatively short space of time,
    And simple fact is it will take years to implement as generally ur only replacing a dog every 7-8 yrs so u can't just spring it on stalkers, even if they bought a new pup for the law it will take a year or so to get it up to standard
    This is pretty much how I'm thinking. It would be pointless to force Lamping contractors to have dogs trained to a set of rules that don't meet their requirements. A contractor doesn't need a tracking dog, but one that goes and finds a shot deer in the dark. One that finds the shot site. I would imagine that would be absolutely contrary to the training of any of these scent hounds. I know if I had trained a scent hound to that standard, I'd be pretty reluctant to take it out lamping!
    The more I learn about people, the more I like my dog.

  6. #6
    Mibee every stalker has there own way of doing things, but i'd imagine most work as a 2/3 man team and u send the other person to find the deer while the lamp man keeps the spot marked and lite.
    I doubt they ae not recovring many shot/dead deer as thats money in there pocket, and to be honest i doubt there losing many injured deer either.

    Was actually speaking to a boy last night about this, i knew he culled a lot but the numbers shocked me wot he culls himself, and he stalks with a dog but says u rarely need to use it

    So i think it possibly may push for deer to be followed the next morning rather than working a dog at night which also follows most of the scent boys ideas for best practice.
    To be honest dunno how happy i would be casting a dog of over a restock site at night, ur really asking for an injury to ur dog with so many holes and jaggy branches, seen them walked to heel over to shot sight thou so only a small hunt round the immediate area.

    I totally agree with there being some standard, but i think have to be careful its not too high, i don't really think there is much of a problem as it is (or mibee the boys that i know that do it are decnt proffessionals) incase u scare people off.
    The stalkers should really be able to get to most shot sites within 8-12 hrs really so slightly diferent than the scent hound/recovery assoc's as they could be 2 days or longer depending on distances and handlers work commitments

    The problem will be with it written by civil servants with no idea wot goes on or how ur meant to work the dogs

  7. #7
    Problems have been raised and I am sure many are now aware that lamping will become the norm in Scotland. There is also talk of night vision and thermal. While most lampers were contractors who had to adhere to the FC standard. This will no doubt change and with that change comes the problem of people with no dog lamping and people with dogs that are not fit for the purpose. Same as the night vison stuff standards will need to be set. No point saying you have a dog when all it can do is keep the passenger seat warm or run deer on to busy roads and cause problems. No point some one having 80.000 pounds worth of thermol gear when I can get one for 200 for my phone. I think there needs to be a standard and it needs to be very high or deer will suffer and be found by the public or hit on busy roads.
    As I get older I have realised that I cannot please everyone. But I find I can easy piss every one off.

  8. #8
    I think it's pretty much standard practice to take your dog out to find every deer that you shoot in a lamp. All the rangers that I know walk their dog to heel out to the rough area that the deer was shot and then cast the dog off. 9 times out of 10, they're within 20-50 metres of the deer and the dog finds the deer really quickly. Usually, you could find the deer yourself with a torch so it's not at all necessary to use a dog but it could save half an hour (or more) for every animal you shoot. Time is money when you're at that game.

    Now, you don't need a particularly well trained dog to do that (although, all of the dogs that I've seen that do it are very well trained) as it's not particularly difficult work. I would suggest that dogs like these learn as they go and tend to be able to find the vast majority of deer that they're asked to find. For the deer that they can't find, there are now dedicated tracking groups (UKSHA & UKDTR) that are willing to come out to search. I don't personally see any need for the lampers dog to be trained in anything other than recall and possibly walking to heel, and heel is only necessary if they've lost their lead and recall could be dispensed with by using a long lead. Really all it needs is its nose.
    The more I learn about people, the more I like my dog.

  9. #9
    [QUOTE=countrryboy;1163200]Are u not already meant to have a 'trained deer dog' just that they never set a standard.

    I don't think ur ever going to have a dog that tracks in the dark, not because the dog can't do it, would make no odds to the dog but because the human isn't capable off following safely or reading the dog.


    Humans are more than capable of successfully tracking with dogs over a variety of terrains in the dark. Police dog handlers have been successfully doing it for years. If anything the dogs heightened senses in the dark are more obvious to read.

    Cant say I would be keen trying to use a tracking line over restock in the dark, especially with a really drivey dog!

    Spotlight held on shot sight, walk out with dog at heel then cast off from shot sight off lead is far more practical and a dog with the ability to bring a mobile deer to bay is preferable.

    Not too sure how you would consistently replicate that scenario in an "assessed" exercise?

    Regards

    BP

  10. #10
    [QUOTE=Ben P;1163331]
    Quote Originally Posted by countrryboy View Post
    Are u not already meant to have a 'trained deer dog' just that they never set a standard.

    I don't think ur ever going to have a dog that tracks in the dark, not because the dog can't do it, would make no odds to the dog but because the human isn't capable off following safely or reading the dog.


    Humans are more than capable of successfully tracking with dogs over a variety of terrains in the dark. Police dog handlers have been successfully doing it for years. If anything the dogs heightened senses in the dark are more obvious to read.

    Cant say I would be keen trying to use a tracking line over restock in the dark, especially with a really drivey dog!

    Spotlight held on shot sight, walk out with dog at heel then cast off from shot sight off lead is far more practical and a dog with the ability to bring a mobile deer to bay is preferable.

    Not too sure how you would consistently replicate that scenario in an "assessed" exercise?

    Regards

    BP
    Aye but wot u are saying makes sense but not really the 'european way' that is being talked about.

    And thats the difference ur tallking about tracking over restock sites or into thick conifer plantations which are usually a pita in daylight, never mind at night.
    I doubt many polis would track someone at night over a restock site, there H&S would never allow it

    If u bring a mobile deer to bay, wot happens next? In pitch black u have to get spotlight on it and then shoot it, just everything is a lot more difficut at night (even checking safe back stops etc quickly) means u almost need 2 folk to be followingthe dog, have added noise of walking at night and also most of the tracking orgs recommend leaing it 4hrs+ depending on injury so ur really almost into the morning anyway

    Must admit we usualy just walk out to the spot with ur own lamp and look around by hand withut a dog, can see it being useful in some circumstances thou. nd know a few boys that do it that way occasionally

Similar Threads

  1. contractors rifle
    By pendle in forum Rifles & Calibres
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 15-02-2013, 23:58
  2. Minimum training standard??
    By Shabz in forum Training and Qualifications
    Replies: 65
    Last Post: 05-07-2012, 16:48
  3. Lamping deer
    By sakoson in forum Deer Stalking General
    Replies: 44
    Last Post: 07-06-2012, 00:28
  4. Redding Standard vs Deluxe vs RCBS Standard vs Competition
    By maffs in forum Ammunition, Reloading & Ballistics
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 12-05-2012, 17:59
  5. illuminated reicle or standard for deer at last light?
    By mel in forum Equipment & Accessories
    Replies: 33
    Last Post: 25-01-2011, 23:19

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •