Page 2 of 7 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 69

Thread: FC disgusting practices in the Forest of Dean?

  1. #11
    Yeh that's cool, shoot them out if it's a must but with a bit of seasonal consideration for welfare or is that thrown out the window because of an excuse??? This is not anti orientated DD but every hunter has a welfare responsibility and... Put your hand up now if you're morally ok with shooting sows with dependant young then???

    Sorry if that's blunt but that's what you need to be cool with. Maybe I'm just a softy then who should keep quiet so long as everyone else pretends that's fine and dandy

    This post started as a question not a statement
    Last edited by Paul at Fechan; 17-08-2011 at 11:09.

  2. #12
    Account Suspended
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Bonnie Scotland
    Posts
    3,447
    [QUOTE=eggy s;248985]The UK should have a zero tolerance policy on wild boar.QUOTE]

    Why?

  3. #13
    I would like to think the the FC are a little more considerate with their policy, and the I am sure the rangers I know would not consider shooting pregnant / lactating sows without good reason. I am not sure what figures are available as to the estimated number of boar in the FOD, but they do seem to be increasing at a good rate; I do know the FOC shoot / trap lots of them! The damage they do is incredible, perhaps not so visible at this time of year as the ground is too hard, but I speak to plenty of folks round here who are throughly p****d off with them. A few weeks ago we had an area of potatoes turned over and wasted, a few days later the broad beans were flattened!! We have fences pushed up which my pointer can walk through without touching the wire!! They are incredible animals and here to stay!

    ATB

    T

  4. #14
    [QUOTE=Tamus;249067]
    Quote Originally Posted by eggy s View Post
    The UK should have a zero tolerance policy on wild boar.QUOTE]

    Why?
    True Wild Boar have been extinct in the UK since the 13th century.
    Over the years people have tried to reintroduce them (16th and 17th century) and every time they have tried they have been hunted in to extinction again. 1. They are highly destructive to agricultural crops which are already under high enough demand.
    2. With the last wolf being shot in the 17th century they now have no natural predators.
    3. Much of their main habitat has now been destroyed which is likely to push them into more frequent conflicts with man.

  5. #15
    Why are the FC wasteing tax payers money shooting wild boar? They do not damage their product, the trees, so therefore no need to cull them.

  6. #16
    Account Suspended
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Bonnie Scotland
    Posts
    3,447
    [QUOTE=eggy s;249076]
    Quote Originally Posted by Tamus View Post

    True Wild Boar have been extinct in the UK since the 13th century.
    Over the years people have tried to reintroduce them (16th and 17th century) and every time they have tried they have been hunted in to extinction again. 1. They are highly destructive to agricultural crops which are already under high enough demand.
    2. With the last wolf being shot in the 17th century they now have no natural predators.
    3. Much of their main habitat has now been destroyed which is likely to push them into more frequent conflicts with man.
    Agricultural crop production, ie. food production, in the UK is a marginal industry of ever diminishing importance, as evidenced by the ongoing decline in political will to secure such production. By contrast wild boar hunting is a growth industry generating real, new and unsubsidised financial returns and employment and is therefore an important fillip, throwing it's presently small lifeline to the fragile rural economy, much may it grow and prosper.

    You are correct, there are no wolves yet (thank goodness) but there is the motor car, a voracious killer. Control measures to reduce the number of speed related fatalities and injuries on rural byeways might be a spin off benefit of more wild boar based traffic calming measures randomly appearing around the country. This can only be hoped for as a means to aid in curing man's self destructive use of the said motor car.

    However, in conflicts between man and wild boar (such as you perhaps intend in your mentionings) my natural sympathies tend to lie with the underdog. In any case in Mano-a-Scrofa related face-offs the pig usually runs away faster than any man can chase.

    As to the lack of habitat, isn't that always cited as being one of the ultimate sins of modern farmers. Any increase in wildboar must surely serve to alleviate such allegations against a marginal and ethnically minor group. Yes/No?

    So, all in all and on the basis of the answers you supplied, I'm afraid I cannot presently form the view that your initial statement, which I questioned, has any validity.

  7. #17
    eggy, that's very true although how is the case of the boar any different to the muntjac, CWD, sika and fallow who are all introduced (about 70k deer related accidents a year now isn't it?). The boar became extinct because of habitat loss and conflict with man and while there are no wolves here we are their natural predator now.

    The land dynamic of the UK is very different to say France and Germany where the boar population has boomed and there is far more prime habitat for their survival and most importantly space. We are a heavily popuated island and our percentage woodland cover compared to Europe is far less and heavily biased toward commercial plantations in many parts of the UK. Realistically there are many areas where the wild boar can flourish here but this is not everywhere and the risks of a Germany type situation is unrealistic.

    Most large wild mammals come into conflict with man in some way. Deer, fox, now boar and the list goes on so why not just appreciate that they are there and go with it as best we can. Hells bells, the Sika destroy my hardwoods up North in a big way but I wouldn't wish them gone so deal with it as best I can.

  8. #18
    [QUOTE=eggy s;249076]
    Quote Originally Posted by Tamus View Post

    True Wild Boar have been extinct in the UK since the 13th century.
    Over the years people have tried to reintroduce them (16th and 17th century) and every time they have tried they have been hunted in to extinction again. 1. They are highly destructive to agricultural crops which are already under high enough demand.
    2. With the last wolf being shot in the 17th century they now have no natural predators.
    3. Much of their main habitat has now been destroyed which is likely to push them into more frequent conflicts with man.
    So we just need to reintroduce the wolf, which might also get help reducing the number of:
    a. campers
    b. hill walkers
    c. Vagabonds

  9. #19
    Account Suspended
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Bonnie Scotland
    Posts
    3,447
    [QUOTE=PKL;249105]
    Quote Originally Posted by eggy s View Post

    So we just need to reintroduce the wolf, which might also get help reducing the number of:
    a. campers
    b. hill walkers
    c. Vagabonds
    Can't argue with logic like that

    They certainly won't take down many healthy deer, like wot they're meant to, according to these guys:

    http://www.wolvesandhumans.org/wolve...troduction.htm

    I'm a creature of little brain so maybe I don't know that them wooly maggots is actually a type of deer, of course

    Happy stalking, and TTFN

  10. #20
    "Agricultural crop production, ie. food production, in the UK is a marginal industry of ever diminishing importance, as evidenced by the ongoing decline in political will to secure such production. By contrast wild boar hunting is a growth industry generating real, new and unsubsidised financial returns and employment and is therefore an important fillip, throwing it's presently small lifeline to the fragile rural economy, much may it grow and prosper."

    Agriculture pumps in 5 billion into the economy. Food production equates to 8% of the UK Economy. Marginal ?? Are you being serious??
    Shooting relates to 1.6 billion. Of which I very much doubt that more than 1 million is generated from shooting wild boar in the UK. I don't see how it creates employment as the people doing the guiding are normally deer stalkers anyway. I am pleased to see you value the odd Wild Boar that people pay to shoot over the lively hood of the farmers who's crops they destroy.


    "You are correct, there are no wolves yet (thank goodness) but there is the motor car, a voracious killer. Control measures to reduce the number of speed related fatalities and injuries on rural byeways might be a spin off benefit of more wild boar based traffic calming measures randomly appearing around the country. This can only be hoped for as a means to aid in curing man's self destructive use of the said motor car. "

    You are comparing a natural predator to something that could result in the lose of human lives. I just did a quick google search on car crashed relating to wild boar in the UK, not highly scientific but there are a whopping 2 articles relating to this one from 2002 and one from 2010. Hardly the control a natural predator would inflict on the population now is it.

    "However, in conflicts between man and wild boar (such as you perhaps intend in your mentionings) my natural sympathies tend to lie with the underdog. In any case in Mano-a-Scrofa related face-offs the pig usually runs away faster than any man can chase.

    As to the lack of habitat, isn't that always cited as being one of the ultimate sins of modern farmers. Any increase in wildboar must surely serve to alleviate such allegations against a marginal and ethnically minor group. Yes/No?"

    My comment relating to conflicts between man and wild boar relates to everything:
    From increased agricultural damage
    Increased car accidents
    Increased woodland damage
    etc etc.


    "So, all in all and on the basis of the answers you supplied, I'm afraid I cannot presently form the view that your initial statement, which I questioned, has any validity."

    Each to their own, but I could not work out if your questioning was meant to be comical or not. I have been instructed to kill any wild boar on sight should I ever encounter any on my ground so I can assure you I am not alone in my beliefs therefore they have validity.

Similar Threads

  1. Forest of Dean Cull
    By paul k in forum Wild Boar
    Replies: 44
    Last Post: 20-05-2017, 16:53
  2. Cull in Forest of Dean
    By jack in forum Wild Boar
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 05-09-2011, 21:12
  3. Wanted Fallow/fox shooting ross/forest of dean/herefordshire
    By RETIC80 in forum Deer Stalking Opportunities
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 11-05-2011, 21:36
  4. PNEUDART/DAVEJELEN Forest of Dean Red Stag.
    By Bill Bartlett in forum Deer Stalking General
    Replies: 24
    Last Post: 01-05-2011, 12:33
  5. Boar kills greyhound in the Forest Of Dean
    By BenB in forum Wild Boar
    Replies: 24
    Last Post: 02-06-2010, 10:29

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •