Trouble is none will do all the jobs.
If you want to keep your hands warm and dry then a Gotex pair of sking gloves/mitts are the best Only buy gortex, everything else will leak. Mine work at -30c ontop of some mountains in Switzerland.
I have a pair of cammo neoprene gloves with fold back fingers which are good, available in most fishing tackle shops. Wear them when lamping at night particular when using hand held lamp from a moving vechicle.
Couple of years ago I read a review in gun mart for leather waterproof gloves. Purchased a pair for my dad who swears by them. Can't remember the maker/supplier.
Dont like woolen fingerless mitts as seem to attract every bramble/briar in area.
D