Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15

Thread: Why is it ethical to kill deer but let the badgers live?

  1. #1
    SD Regular willie_gunn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Oxfordshire, Wiltshire, Berkshire....and Sutherland
    View my Gallery (19)View my Gallery (19)

    Why is it ethical to kill deer but let the badgers live?

    O wad some Power the giftie gie us to see oursels as ithers see us!

  2. #2
    "To philosophers of animal rights, "conservation culling" is an Orwellian atrocity – "speciesism" in action. And conservationists – and I include myself in this group – sometimes flounder in the face of such clear and principled thinking."

  3. #3
    Account Suspended
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Bonnie Scotland
    Quote Originally Posted by Klenchblaize View Post
    "To philosophers of animal rights, "conservation culling" is an Orwellian atrocity – "speciesism" in action. And conservationists – and I include myself in this group – sometimes flounder in the face of such clear and principled thinking."
    "Conservation" from the verb "to conserve" .... It is an action, it is done, an intervention if you will. Nothing more to explain than that really.

  4. #4
    SD Regular Mr. Gain's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    SW Birmingham (Rubery Rednal)
    He seems to have adopted the rhetoric and selective science of the anthropomorphists while conceding some of the logic of the wildlife managers and doing his inadequate best to appear impartial...

    As for the final statement:

    "we are custodians of the natural world and must make difficult decisions when a deer's right to life comes into conflict with the right to life of an aspen sapling or a capercaillie".

    Who are "we"? Our government? The wildlife trusts? The animal rights extremists? The fluffy bunny brigade? or the people with an immediate and practical -and not merely emotional- concern for the matter: i.e. landowners, farmers, and sportsmen?

    Also, since when did an animal have a "right to life"?

    More anthropomorphism. And his distaste for farming and profit is palpable - though presumably he took a fee for the article and pours milk on his muesli in the morning.

    Can you hear the sound of my teeth grinding?
    "Docendo discimus" - Seneca the Younger (c. 4 BC – 65 AD)
    “Comodidad, tranquilidad y buena alimentacion” - A Spanish recipe for contentment that oddly omits hunting.
    "I'm off to spend some time at the top of the food chain..." - (after) Tulloch
    "Oh [dear], they probably heard that in the village!" - RickoShay

  5. #5
    Reading it, he's not actually that bad - just a bit confused. It reads like a rushed undergraduate essay that lazily borrows common concepts and rhetorical tropes without bothering to fully understand things or develop a robust argument.

    At least, on balance, he is not flat out opposed to all culling.

  6. #6
    I spotted that a couple of weeks ago but didn't post it here because I didn't think anyone here would like it much, and also mainly because I had other things on. Anyway, the point is that it's an external perspective to our own, actually quite a balanced one, and we have to live with other users of the natural world, and even people who just like to know that it exists without really ever having much to do with it directly. We all share the same space, and once you remove the ethical and emotional arguments, what we're talking about here is how we choose to explot and develop competing renewable natural ressources. We're used to the competing needs of forestry ("no deer!"), sporting interests ("Better deer!"), animal rights types ("More deer!"), highland agriculture ("More sheep!"), etc. Well on top of that, it's legitimate for some to want to swap some deer for some capercaillie, some badgers for some cows, some "deer forests" for some actual forests, and even some green belt for some houses. There's only so much space and there are competing demands for it. It comes down to balance, compromise, openness and collaboration. We may have to compromise. So will everyone else. Mountain bikers and ramblers too. It's either that, or the strongest party wins, and that's probably not us in the long run.

  7. #7
    Has anyone tried to eat a badger ?

    "This year will go down in history. For the first time, a civilized nation has full gun registration. Our streets will be safer, our police more efficient, and the world will follow our lead into the future!"
    Adolph Hitler – 1933

  8. #8
    I refuse to read that anti hunting rag.
    It has a number of posts by well known ant activists.
    One notable article made by the head of PETA. You just try and comment to correct the lies and your comment just gets removed.
    Obviously questioning their "journalists" with all their "knowledge and research" is not the done thing.

  9. #9
    If Brock causes that much damage [allegedly] why are they protected...

  10. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by waterford103 View Post
    Has anyone tried to eat a badger ?

    Someone I know made badger ham a while ago from a fresh roadkill near his shoot and apparently it was very good!!
    Follow my stalking journey & SD sponsored DSC1 progress blog here

    DSC1 forum sponsorship - Blogs - The Stalking Directory

Similar Threads

  1. Use of shotgun to kill deer
    By daw in forum Legal Issues
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: 12-02-2016, 20:44
  2. 2011 Live Capture, Immobilisation & Live Deer Handling Course
    By Jelendeer in forum Deer Stalking General
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 29-04-2012, 20:59
  3. What does it take to kill a deer?
    By Iwrch in forum Deer Stalking General
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: 28-06-2010, 23:10
  4. How on earth can you kill a Deer!!!!
    By Joshua in forum Deer Stalking General
    Replies: 29
    Last Post: 08-05-2010, 11:12
  5. Ethical free-ranger saying hello from New Zealand
    By ethical-freeranger in forum Introductions
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 04-09-2008, 08:00

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts