Ive had Altberg defenders for years now and love them, comfortable and though no goretex liner, waterproof when treated with ledergris, (I always wear sealskin knee length socks anyway to ensure against wet feet.) always found them hard wearing and comfortable, my only slight criticism is the rubber rand doesn't extend up the toe and on beating days you can get a fair bit of wear on the leather direct. To that end I bought a pair of Haix mil issue goretex, but although great build quality these ones are a bit narrow for my feet, and the goretex lining takes longer to dry out so I'll personally stick with Altbergs I reckon. depends on your feet size/fit but they are both excellent boots at a brilliant price (around £75), to me its a total waste of money spending hundreds on named brands that often dont work as well or worse.