I can see Namman's point as it applies to revolvers: the case head cannot do any thing but reverse under recoil held as it is. In that rearward motion, a revolver's recoil is akin to the behaviour of an inertia hammer.
In the case of a rifle the cartridge is held fairly snuggly, but not as per a revolver. It can move. I would tend to think that John's estimation is on the money: Cartridge is not held fast in a rifle, rifle and magazine are moving rearward...the next force being applied to the cartridge must be the front of the magazine pushing the bullet inward.
In the case of a rifle the cartridge is held fairly snuggly, but not as per a revolver. It can move. I would tend to think that John's estimation is on the money: Cartridge is not held fast in a rifle, rifle and magazine are moving rearward...the next force being applied to the cartridge must be the front of the magazine pushing the bullet inward.
)

