I see your point, but have to ask, honestly. How does adding another layer (government funding) make healthcare either better, or lower cost?Which may well be better. Rather than ban sugar for all to "Save the NHS" we could just charge fatties more. Other examples available - dangerous activities for example.
Or we provide a basic level of cover via state funding and allow people to top up their own cover (Irish model).
Either way, the funding could be separate from the provision to allow the consumer the choice of where they are treated. Current NHS is run for the benefit of the organisation rather than the people using it.
And don't even get me started on the sheer number of mothers & babies the NHS has killed due to dogma and incompetence in maternity wards.
Your argument/point completely brushes over this.