Red dot sight for deer hunting?

Whilst i can comprehend the attraction, i cant visualise the benefit of such a device over a good quality optic (with or without illuminated ret), ok for kicking doors in and brassing the place up, but no place in english woodland. No stalker i know would use one or entertain a guest/client with one. I use a 4-16x50 zeiss with ret 60 illuminated dot, covers me nicely from 5 to 500y, further on gongs and targets.
 
I've used EOTecchs for quite some years now (going back to when they were solely marketed under Bushnell's "Holosight" brand). Today's EOTech sights are light years ahead of what they were initially, and good sights for snap shooting and close, rapid shots.

Downside? Batteries and power saving feature. Seems they always shut off at the inopportune time. When you add in the magnifier, I start to raise the "there are better options" flag.

When you figure you spend roughly $500 US for the EOTech sight, and almost another $500 US (or more) for the 3x magnifier, (IMHO) its time to start looking at the ACOG sights that use light gathering fiber optics (no battery) and are a straight 3x magnification.

As far as the sight plane delta/difference; while it does exist, I think real world applications are kind of a moot point for most calibers. 3" low is still going to punch a lung on a deer size animal, and in my experience people tend to hold over too much anyways.

Nothing against EOTech's, I have many of them myself. But when we start talking over $1000 US, I start thinking its time to move up to something else.

As far as Aimpoints...I've had stellar and abysmal products from them. When they work, they work well. When they don't...well, sometimes lessons are learned the hard way...
 
horses for courses tbh
the eotech units work great on rabbits where you need a good field of view. the magnifier adds a little extra confidence/flexibility but yes I'd agree if you were paying the new prices you'd be better looking at the Zeiss or swaro 1.5-6 type scopes. if you are seriously well heeled then perhaps one of the current dual mag Elcan units for several thousand squid.


my red dot use is limited to a mini reflex unit mounted on a special ARMS ring to help with quick alignment and picking up the target in the main scope. My Swaro doesnt have turget turrets so no issue there
I'm mainly in the 200-300m range on the clearfell so I doubt I'd use the reflex dot to shoot unless it was a short range surprise :)
 
Back
Top