Foxyboy43
Well-Known Member
Indeed - there and the Somme never fail to move me each time I visit.I too have been to Ypres many times and walked the sites of all three major battles. The first use of chlorine gas was at Ypres April 1915 against French colonial troops. Unbelievably the Canadians stubbornly refused to retreat.
We must beg to differ on your views on the British High Command!
My good pal has the trench diary of his uncle who was initially based at what is now the Bellegarde crater and ālivedā in a dugout underneath the Menin Road in conditions of absolute squalor. We also have his handwritten account of an attack which won him a Mention in Dispatches which cost many lives at no gain - like so many others before and after. Sadly he was killed on the River Lys in January 1916. His diary includes the entry he made that morning just before he led his men in an attack on the german trenches together with hand-written eye-witness accounts of his courage which ultimately won him an MC. This soldier was the only son of a Belfast Shipbuilding magnate and is the centrepiece of a wonderful memorial to him and 135 other shipyard men who also lost their lives in the Great War. A small group of family and friends gathered at the memorial on the 100th anniversary of the memorialās unveiling and a prayer was read from his trench bible. A remarkable young man who gave up a directorship and a very bright future in his fatherās business to defend King and Country and like so many others lost his life.
I do of course understand your views on the GS but IMHO Ypres was of no strategic military value, was a salient surrounded and dominated on three sides from the outset by enemy who could see virtually every movement. Just a few hundred yards away was the much easier to defend canal which already formed the basis of a strong defensive position elsewhere outside the town and yet we clung to it at a devastating cost. It could have been evacuated at any time and as a result the attrition rate aka slaughter could have been much reduced. A view shared by many of those who survived.