I’ve not read the whole thread.
To my mind there’s a clear relationship between accidents like this, and the European habit of carrying a loaded rifle when stalking and relying on the safety, as loading a rifle when presented with a shot is regarded as too slow and/or too noisy. If you make a mistake and forget to check the rifle is clear before stowing it, the likelihood of there being a chambered round is massively reduced if you aren’t in the habit of loading one when you don’t need it.
There are YouTube videos of European hunters getting out of the car, removing the rifle from it’s case, chambering a round and slinging it over their shoulder and walking off. That’s a massive no-no in this part of the world. Here, if you accidentally shoot someone in circumstances like this, it means you’ve broken the rules of the Firearms Code, which you promised you wouldn’t do when you signed the firearms licence forms. So if you do you’re in deep shite.
We’ve argued about it ad nauseam on here before and believe me I can’t be bothered to do it again. So I’ll state it as an inarguable fact and if you choose to argue then you haven’t read this sentence properly.
Glad the guide is recovered, and feel some small degree of sympathy for the man that shot him, as sadly one of the common adages that applies universally to all mankind is “we all make mistakes”.