Read the FSA Wild Game Guide. That's the definitive document. You need to register as a Food Business with your LA even if all you do is take carcasses direct from the field to an AGHE.
I wrote about it in post #1 here:
In a recent thread on here it became aparent that lots of people (myself included) weren't aware that registration as a food business would be required even if all you do is transfer carcasses directly from the field to an AGHE. Following that discussion, I have registered as a food business...
www.thestalkingdirectory.co.uk
In some cases, you may need to educate your local EHO about the requirement, because unless they've dealt with such an application before they may not be aware of the Wild Game legislation. But the onus is on you to be compliant. It'll be you that's up to the neck in it when the sh1t hits the fan, not the person who gave you poor advice.
BASC is giving poor advice in this case, it would appear.
We are very fortunate to be able to sell carcasses and venison. The legislation surrounding Wild Game is far more relaxed than that for domestic livestock. However, if stalkers persist in cutting corners and deliberately failing to comply with the existing guidelines then they'll be tightened. And we don't want that.