Case length....what happens if i don't trim my cases?

Most reloaders load not to save money but to form accurate rounds.
Not me! I reload so that i can fire rounds without seeing the bank balance drop too quickly. If i got out bunny bashing with a 222 i might shoot 20-40 rounds. If i do that 3 times per week it'll soon get expensive. Then on top we count my 243 and 300wm. I shoot my 300wm plenty, i'd hate to shoot it at the volume i do with factory prices. I load it for roughly £1 a bang give or take, I couldn't do that with factory.
 
I remember a 1917 Enfield (30-06) that had the receiver ring blown off of it with a 180 grain cast bullet over 15 grains of Alliant Unique: A very tame load. Examination of the unfired rounds in the block showed that the cases were all over-length.

I hate trimming as much as I hate cleaning primer pockets but both need to be done, and trimming should be done. Time consuming, yes, but a vital part of the process. It amazed me that people will trickle each charge to an exactitude and not begrudge the amount of time spent on the task, yet will think trimming a bother.~Muir
 
I remember a 1917 Enfield (30-06) that had the receiver ring blown off of it with a 180 grain cast bullet over 15 grains of Alliant Unique: A very tame load. Examination of the unfired rounds in the block showed that the cases were all over-length.

I hate trimming as much as I hate cleaning primer pockets but both need to be done, and trimming should be done. Time consuming, yes, but a vital part of the process. It amazed me that people will trickle each charge to an exactitude and not begrudge the amount of time spent on the task, yet will think trimming a bother.~Muir
I agree, it takes time and must be done or you risk bad things, as you well know. Idk why more don't read the caution section of printed load manuals.
 
To be sure people who “Reload ammunition” should understand that many of the procedures are there for a reason, that being your’s and anyone near you, along with your firearm’s safety, A good long sit down with a read of the thread on here, reloading from fired case etc.
 
Typically it's my Blaser R93 .222 that needs the cases trimming. I full length resize which often means i need to trim .001-003 thou off everytime, which i guess will eventually lead to a case head separation? I've always been told to FL resize for a blaser so lets not go down that rabbit hole.

I guess i need to do some trimming then, FYI the .005 example in my opening post was just a worst case, not actually what they are. :)
I also shoot a R93 in .222 Rem. I only F/L size every 4th or 5th cycle. This is then also coherent with the need to trim the cases.
The same goes for several other calibers both in R93 and R8 rifles. They are the most forgiving rifles I know when it comes to accepting neck sized brass.
Whoever told you that a R93 would require F/L sizing every time obviously never own one himself.

As for the trimming procedure as such, here is a link to something I posted some time ago (post #4). It has taken the horror out of trimming for me.
Case cleaning
 
Last edited:
My post at #17 was a genuine query.

Does/can brass "grow" as a result of FL resizing?

It feels counterintuitive to me.
Measure after firing, then after sizing. No sarcasm intended, the shoulder forms to the chamber, when you push it back the neck gets longer. look at the post where phillips 321 posted the dimensions before and after sizing.:tiphat:
 
Measure after firing, then after sizing. No sarcasm intended, the shoulder forms to the chamber, when you push it back the neck gets longer. look at the post where phillips 321 posted the dimensions before and after sizing.
No sarcasm taken - the Gods did not bless me with much, but on the plus side, totally forgot to give me an ego.

I saw the post regarding the measurements before and after sizing - which caused me to pose the (genuine) question.

As always, everyday a school day on SD.
 
I hate trimming as much as I hate cleaning primer pockets but both need to be done, and trimming should be done. Time consuming, yes, but a vital part of the process.
I don't understand this at all. As I mentioned earlier, I use a Lee trim die for all three of the calibres I reload for, along with the Lee Quick Trim deluxe, and it literally takes a couple of seconds per case. It also serves as a valuable opportunity for me to give each case a final once-over prior to charging and bullet-seating
 
My post at #17 was a genuine query.

Does/can brass "grow" as a result of FL resizing?

It feels counterintuitive to me.

Yes. It does.

When you FL size, most of the case gets squished back to where it was before firing. You can't compress brass, it has to "flow" somewhere. There is only one way for it to go, in a sizing die, and that is forwards.

So, gradually the case becomes thinner. The brass that has been pushed out, and trimmed off, came from the body of the case.

Other mechanisms are also at work as the round is fired, but basically all of them cause the brass to flow forwards. Hence the need to trim it off, once it gets near to the end of the neck part of the chamber. Let it get beyond that, and bad things could happen.
 
When you FL size, most of the case gets squished back to where it was before firing. You can't compress brass, it has to "flow" somewhere. There is only one way for it to go, in a sizing die, and that is forwards.

Thank you, and in simple language which allows me to think in "pictures" which is how my mind works.
 
I don't understand this at all. As I mentioned earlier, I use a Lee trim die for all three of the calibres I reload for, along with the Lee Quick Trim deluxe, and it literally takes a couple of seconds per case. It also serves as a valuable opportunity for me to give each case a final once-over prior to charging and bullet-seating
I have a slightly different approach to case trimming as I trim to the shortest case in the LOT. This makes it a little more complicated. I measure each case, setting the shortest to the side until I find one shorter to replace it. When I find it, I use that case to set the cutter on my Forster, and trim the rest. I can measure 50 cases witha dial calipers in a few minutes. It's time consuming but I make up for it by having an exceptionally good powder meter that allows me throw accurate charges straight into the case. No weighing and trickling. On a rainy afternoon with time to kill I'll use my TargetMaster just for the fun of watchng it work.

To the point. Trimming needs to be done. If people actually read the loading manuals, or studied the mechanics of reloading they would not need to ask the effect of not trimming cases.~Muir
 
I have a slightly different approach to case trimming as I trim to the shortest case in the LOT. This makes it a little more complicated.
Ah, I see. I don't worry about measuring my cases as I just trim them using the Lee die. I envy you being able to throw straight to the cases. In fact, I now have a slightly bitter twist to my mouth, and I can actually feel my eyes have narrowed :lol:
 
This has made me nervous! So long as my brass is still within the lee case measurements I’ve always assumed I’m okay? I use tame loads and have never found brass to get longer. Is that normal?
 
This has made me nervous! So long as my brass is still within the lee case measurements I’ve always assumed I’m okay? I use tame loads and have never found brass to get longer. Is that normal?
IMHO the clue is in “tame loads”. I too use mid-range charges in all my reloading, particularly the 222 and it is only infrequently that you will see any major difference (usually from different manufacturers/brass quality) in length BEFORE resizing - as per earlier post. I know from hard experience long ago that the hotter the load, the longer the fired case will be, the greater the working of the brass, the greater the wear on the brass, the need for more frequent trimming and as a result the shorter the life of said brass - frequently the cause of incipient case separation. As before - for all my stalking needs and the distances I shoot I simply do not need or use “hot loads”. I have no recollection of any fox or deer ever running on after they were fairly hit by a bullet travelling c.100/200 fps slower than the round could have been. Importantly and for clarity that is not to say that for the much longer ranges frequently seen in for example the US, a stouter charge is not appropriate, in terms of achieving optimum bullet performance alone the additional speed is de rigeur.
🦊🦊
 
Hi all,

I hate trimming my cases, it's probably the worst job of reloading and i need to trim, then chamfer the inside and outside, and measure length again.

If my cases are 0.005thou over SAMMI is that a problem? Just what can go wrong?

I understand that different neck lengths can possibly cause varying tension on the projectile but from a safety perspective what risks are there? If too long can the brass touch the lands?

Thanks in advance
How are you measuring the 0.005 thou?
Most tools are grossly inaccurate and incapable of that level of accuracy

trim with the Lee Case length gauge and only trim when it is necessary as it wont cut below book length
 
Back
Top