As they’re intended to be used at more extended ranges than this yes, the test was simply to see they worked under conditions that gave the bullet every opportunity to do so. When I set out I was aware trying these on a chest shot at 40-50m ish could be messy, but ordinarily I would have head/neck shot at this range so not a concern. This test has simply given me a confidence to use them at more range. My standard shot over clearfell and open hill averages about 200m approximately, hence the choice.
Normally I use the Barnes TTSX for close woodland stalking like this and get very tidy results from them.
On the game dealer point, I cannot speak of many game dealers, as I use only a couple due to locality, but they are happy so long as the carcass is clean and the saddles are intact. If the saddle is damaged that’s when deductions are made. From my understanding they don’t make much money on the front legs anyway.
In any case Virtus do a more limited damage model if that is a concern for you (osprey). I have found them (as a company) brilliant to deal with, having had quick and detailed responses all round, I’m sure they can help you in finding something that will suit your needs.
Ben