On the original subject of a tail amputation.
When comparing costs it is really important to know what was estimated for.
If you take your car in for a "service" that could mean an oil and filter. Or it could mean Oil, air, pollen and fuel filters, engine flush and oil change, brake fluid change, coolant spec check and all catches greased/adjusted.
Likewise with surgery. Is the patient getting a bare bones, knock out anaesthetic, amputate tail, stitch and wake up with 3 days of pain killers?
OR
are they having pre-operative bloods to check basic health status (I found an early hepatitis, with no signs of illness in a patient recently before a routine neutering). Then with the anaesthetic, they get full monitoring with a multiparameter monitor (£4000-£9000), real time temperature logging, specialist warming machine that wont burn them (approx £1000 to buy) instead of rubber gloves filled with hot water which present a scald risk if they burst.
Then are they given an epidural which is considered the best pain relief for this procedure but very technically challenging to perform and not without risks. If not they may receive a constant rate infusion of 2 or 3 pain management medications using specially calibrated infusion machines (anywhere between £600-£800) to try to minimise post operative pain in what is already a very sensitive area. Is the tail then bandaged correctly using tip protection to go home. As regards mediations going home, instead of 3 days of doggy aspirin, they may be getting 3 different pain management medications, one anti-inflammatory, one (maybe 2 painkillers) and in addition they may be getting behaviour modifying medications to help you manage the post operative period as Tail amps have a very high complication rate and often repeat surgery is required if the post op period is not perfect. Does the price paid include a bandage change and check in 2-3 days?
The former option can be successful, absolutely and certainly should be cheaper but it definitely carries a higher complication rate. Then in the event of complications, who bares responsibility? The vet who tried to work within budget constraints or you as the owner who imposed the budget constraints?
Please do not misinterpret me here, I am not white washing veterinary care costs, there are huge variables at play and you may get a better job done for £400 than one that costs you £1100. This is where building a good relationship with your vet comes in. All I am saying is "A Tail Amputation" is not necessarily comparable across the board, there can be an awful lot of difference between one and another.
Whatever you do though, follow the post op care instructions EXACTLY. If you have any concerns regarding your ability to monitor the patient or their likelihood to interfere with the surgical site, discuss them with your vet before or at least at the discharge, this will hopefully help minimise complications. I have had to muzzle/provide mild sedations for one or two particularly obsessive patients to enable us to get the wounds left alone to allow healing to take place.
If you have any questions as regards anything specific feel free to drop a message and I will try to clarify any confusions etc
All the best.