First catch your Salmon...

Easier said than done.

Truth be told, I am not much of a fisherman.

Actually not much of a Stalker either, but let's not go there.

So here we are. It was Monday of our week on Harris - by the Grace of the Hunting Gods, we had somehow made the 700 miles in the most atrocious weather conditions in my memory, but here we were.

Amhuinnsuidhe is one of those places where the 'mythical' Macnab is a possibility.

If you have not already done so, the book by John Buchan explains it all, and is a rather lovely way to spend a day on the hill from the comfort of your own fireside...

The Macnab is a sporting challenge not for the faint of heart, nor come to think of it, those devoid of a sense of humour.

To successfully complete the 'Macnab', you have to catch a Salmon, shoot a brace of Grouse and then a Red Stag - all in one day and all by your own hand. The odds of completing such a feat are as remote as the place you find yourself in, for the bloody attempt.

It is a funny thing (remember what I said about a sense of humour), but you pay for the 'chance' of a Macnab.

The 'chance' of a Macnab involves handing over a pillowcase full of cash, just for the chance. Still got that sense of humour?

If you fail to catch your Salmon, then you do not 'get out of the traps' - and you have handed over a pillowcase full of cash for the privilege of not catching a fish. Just so you know.

Because I didn't...:oops:

Anyhoo.

The Estate Manager (who had met me on the Sunday night outside the larder) had asked me what rod and reel I had brought.

"Rod and reel? Honestly, I am not a real fisherman and so did not bring a rod and reel (actually, I do not own a Salmon rod)"

"So, you have driven 700 miles to have a go at the Macnab and you didn't bring a rod?"


His heavy red eyebrows raised almost imperceptibly, as only a Highland Estate Manager's can - which told me all I needed to know about what he thought about a bloke from the "Smoke" who did not bring a rod on a fishing holiday.

"That's no problem at all sir. The Ghillie will sort something out for you in the morning. He will 'chap' your door at 7. Be ready".

FFS.

I had been driving for two days and wanted a bloody drink. 7 my arse!

In the blink of an eye, it was seven in the morning, and the Ghillie was bagging on the door like an early morning drugs bust.

The sun was barely up, but that, apparently, was enough. The runs and lochs are walkable from the Castle and its associated cottages.

IMG_1317.jpeg


Not being of a religious bent, these times are for me, the nearest I get to a God I do not believe in. It was just beautiful.


IMG_1319.jpeg

The young Ghillie set up his own rod and reel (I should have made a note of what it was, I didn't and that was a mistake) and before I was fully awake, I was flogging some of the most beautiful waters in the Country.


IMG_1320.jpeg

With the young lad by my side, I worked the Beats as directed, and I worked them and worked them...


IMG_1322.jpeg


"If you get a take. Do not strike the rod, just gently raise it. It is not the same as Trout fishing".

The Ghilie (they all seem to do this), smoked a succession of roll-ups throughout the day.

I had no idea what he was on about, but mentally logged his advice.

I was fishing with no expectation of catching, but was rather just enjoying the whole experience. I didn't need to catch a fish to enjoy the day.🤥
Now then. Where is that bastard fish!

Suddenly the tip of the rod bent. For someone who was not bothered about catching a fish, my heart was now pounding like a 'wrong un' at the school gates.

Keeping an outwardly calm appearance, I told the Ghillie to get ready with the massive net that he had brought. I played this fish for all it was worth, and after what seemed an age, brought it safely to the bank.

When I looked down at it, glistening in the sunshine on the grass, I could not help but notice that it was only slightly larger than the fly upon which it had impaled itself.

It was a smolt and funny thing, (remember what I said about a sense of humour) does not count at a Salmon to get you 'out of the traps' on the Macnab.

Before I could take a 'trophy' photo, the Ghillie gently placed it back in the water and it was gone in an instant. I felt the tears welling up in my eyes.

I wanted to say, "You bastard! That was my first ever Salmon!"

What I actually said was, "I have brought a couple of cigars (I am not a real smoker), would you like one?"

We paused in our endeavours and smoked a comedy lardie each - beside some of the most beautiful scenery in the world.

When I die, there is not a chance in Hell I am going to Heaven (see what happened then?) - but I am pretty sure I have seen Paradise.

We then spent a couple of hours on the loch with the boat (he forgot the seat cushions and that became a pain in the arse - literally) but we did not have cause to light another cigar...




IMG_1323.jpeg


I ended the day with a strange desire to go out and purchase my own Salmon rod...but without the required Salmon to successfully compete the Macnab.

For what it's worth. This season at this Estate there has only been one 'successful' Macnab - a young lady from the USA.

C'est la vie.
 
Last edited:
Shame you didn't get a Salmon, but as you say, the scenery and the company make up for it.....
Get yourself a Salmon rod, and give it a serious try, you'll enjoy it more - apart from the fact that it'll make stalking look cheap as chips - and be prepared to empty your bank account(s) in the eternal search for the mythical bar of silver........
 
Get yourself a Salmon rod, and give it a serious try, you'll enjoy it more - apart from the fact that it'll make stalking look cheap...

Notwithstanding the entire trip cost the Grandchildren their long hoped for inheritance...

The costs for the actual day's fishing was (I thought) very reasonable.

You are sill in those wonderful locations, surrounded by the utter beauty of the Highlands & Islands, and are managing to do so without retching up your lungs, trying to stalk into a deer at an altitude which puts you above the local helicopter service.

True story...but that is for later in the week.🥵
 
I guided an American on my local river once, he wanted to catch a wild brown trout, I kid you not he had a tear in his eye when I joked that the voracious fish that took his dry fly was a Salmon, well in fact a Salmon Parr:)

About 30 years ago it was the first day of a weeks trip to Southern Ireland, I hooked into a Salmon with a spinner, I managed to land a fresh run silver Salmon about 10lb, before I had a chance to put it back the river keeper smacked it on the head!
Great, I had intended putting it back, now I had to keep it fresh for a week before I returned back to England!
 
I guided an American on my local river once, he wanted to catch a wild brown trout, I kid you not he had a tear in his eye when I joked that the voracious fish that took his dry fly was a Salmon, well in fact a Salmon Parr:)

About 30 years ago it was the first day of a weeks trip to Southern Ireland, I hooked into a Salmon with a spinner, I managed to land a fresh run silver Salmon about 10lb, before I had a chance to put it back the river keeper smacked it on the head!
Great, I had intended putting it back, now I had to keep it fresh for a week before I returned back to England!

Things I have learned whilst salmon fishing over the years....

Cut into steaks, a 10lb salmon will fit nicely into the freezer box at the top of one of the old-style undercounter fridges.

If you take out all the shelves bar the top one from the door of an American-style fridge-freezer, a 20lb salmon can be hung with space to spare.

Wrapped in sufficient pages from the Inverness Press & Journal, a salmon can stay frozen all the way to Oxfordshire.
 
Been looking forward to to tales of the riverbank and other exploits chasing the big three upt north and great that you had chance to see the place and enjoy the cigar in favourable conditions without been washed away or eaten to death and gel with your surroundings.
Looks like a magical place to visit and spend some time but no doubt dangerous long-term😂
Great to have posted and looking foreword to hearing of the following rollocking adventures, nothing like a good quest!
Interesting jacket the ghillie is sporting anyone know more?
 
Only thing I really learned about catching salmon was to have access to a good supply of “ night crawlers”, spinning rod, large split shot and hooks and a bait that resembled a octopus chucked upstream and allowed to follow the flow till stationary wait five minutes and repeat oft wondered why most fish had bait well down gullet, not funny or clever and possibly not even sporting🤷🏽‍♂️
Should add working on the old adage, “ I prayed for a bike at Christmas, it did not arrive, so stole one and prayed for forgiveness”, sorry! Hat, coat and gone🙏🏻😂😂
 
Don't go too fancy with a "salmon rod" as in the Hebrides a 10 or 11 foot 7 weight single handed "trout" rod is pretty much all you need for everything, and is certainly all I've ever used. The Shakespeare Agility is as good as anything, I'm just back from 5 weeks fishing on Lewis/Harris and the Agility or a Leeda Volare IV (not made any more I think) was pretty much all I used.

Atlantic salmon have been pretty scarce all over this year, even in North America I'm told, so the salmon is always going to be the tricky bit but even more so this year.
 
Don't go too fancy with a "salmon rod" as in the Hebrides a 10 or 11 foot 7 weight single handed "trout" rod is pretty much all you need for everything, and is certainly all I've ever used. The Shakespeare Agility is as good as anything, I'm just back from 5 weeks fishing on Lewis/Harris and the Agility or a Leeda Volare IV (not made any more I think) was pretty much all I used.

Atlantic salmon have been pretty scarce all over this year, even in North America I'm told, so the salmon is always going to be the tricky bit but even more so this year.
I often wonder how hard it was back in Buchan’s time. Surely a lot easier than now?
 
No argument from me on that score...:oops:
It’s the bit of the Macnab that puts me off - you essentially have no control over it at all.

I mean, my instincts tend towards the poachery at the best of times, so the original conception is immensely appealing. If you were able to get a salmon ‘by any means’, it becomes a different prospect. I reckon I could do it if I was allowed to spear fish one…
 
If you were able to get a salmon ‘by any means’, it becomes a different prospect.

A friend tells the story of a (very wealthy) acquaintance of his - recounting how he had four Ghillies trying to hook into a Salmon for him, in order that he could 'land' it, and so go on to have a half-decent chance at the Macnab.

As my friend (a true sportsman) said - "What's the point?"🤔
 
My wife is asking how you got on.

She was out every day with the dogs and often saw a 'fisherman'...

I mostly fished for trout, and mostly on lochs reputed to be "dour" or even to have no fish at all. I like to explore and a bit of a challenge. The trout fishing pretty much went as expected.

I fished 5 days for salmon, basically once the trout was over, for 3 fish. Of the days two were "hopeless" due to conditions but I did have one ideal day when I'd have expected 5+ fish for the day and only managed to lose one and land one so I do believe that there were very limited numbers of fish in the systems and that the runs were down this year.
 
I often wonder how hard it was back in Buchan’s time. Surely a lot easier than now?

I think salmon fishing is sort of a war of attrition in the sense that it is about finding a taking fish. The more fish in any given pool then the more chance that one of them will be a taking fish. Also, if the pool has been fished down by 10 other anglers then the chances are that the taking fish has already taken, whereas if you have the system to yourself and are the first angler to fish it down in a few weeks then those taking fish will still be there waiting for you.

The science seems to indicate that runs are currently well down so this would reduce the chances of there being a taking fish in any given pool and, also, in many places fishing pressure has increased and so you are much less likely to have "exclusive" access to a river and to have all the taking fish solely at your disposal.
 
Back
Top