Hi all,
Anyone using progressive press.
Could you please inform me to how accurate you find your press and which one you have .
Thank you
Hello. I have experience of the RCBS Green Machine, the RCBS 4x4 Auto, the Star, and the Dillon Square Deal and RL 550. I have no experience of the Lee Challenger type system!
Accuracy is down to consistency and ease of achieving that consistency. This consistency is about how well the individual stations "mate" (as it were) with the die that it services. In simple terms the more bulk you have in the base and in the carrousel the more likely (if the indexing system that turns that carrousel is well made) the press is to be accurate. Slop or nearly in nearly out doesn't give consistency just the same as a revolver that doesn't index its cylinder correctly and precisely in the the right place.
The Green Machine was an inline press. It was awful. CH got their inline press right and spot on the Auto Champ Mk IV for example. The Green Machine was a horror. Best thing about it was the big hole where the dies went so that you could run a rope through to use the thing as a boat anchor. It really was that bad!
The RCBS 4x4 Auto has a weakness in that the indexing is fine and is positive but that the rotation of the stations is effected by a rod and nylon washer. Nylon wears the rotation is no longer completed and the thing becomes a PITA. The device is NOT however a write off. Best thing to do with the RCBS 4x4 Auto is to strip out all the automatic functions (rotation - auto primer feeding - auto powder charging) and down convert it, as it were, to basic RCBS 4x$ configuration. To make it effectively a manual progressive. This is easily done.
Star Progressive. Once upon a time rated as the "Rolls Royce" of progressives. Manual or automatic convertible it is all old fashioned steel and brass. If it were a sub-machine gun it'd be a Lanchester to Lee's Challenger Sten. If that analogy makes sense. Heavy, solid, but needs special dies and very old school. Complete a joy and they never break nor bend. But if they arrive to you incomplete then sourcing the parts is like seeking the Holy Grail.
Dillon Square Deal and Dillon RL 550. These both sell well and sell well for a reason. But on the Square Deal the primer feed can be sometimes a bit temperamental. I had one in .44 Magnum and liked it a lot. The RL 550 my local shooting centre run six of them side by side. They have the quirks and foibles but once you work within that system they rarely let you down.
A TIP! PAY ATTENTION! THE BEST SYSTEMS USE CASE OPERATED POWDER CHARGING. THE WORST SYSTEMS USE POWDER CHARGING OPERATED BY A LINKAGE THAT IS DRIVE BY THE ROTATION OF THE PRESS SO DUMPS POWDER EVEN IF NO CASE IS UNDERNEATH THAT POWDER HOPPER.
That's why the Dillon's work and the Lee Challenger types work and why the RCBS 4x4 Auto is best when that rotation driven linkage is disconnected or replaced by a case operated mechanism. The "third way" is where the charging is operated by a fixed post on the press that actions the charging independent of there being a case present or of the rotation of the mechanism. The Star works by this "third way" and works well.