RWC2010,
Do you mind telling me how you would compare the two, given that you use them for different things? Is the fact the Ranger jacket is your nightime jacket mean it is heavier/warmer than the smock, which is maybe more suited to stalking? My fear with the smock was overheating but maybe I'm worrying about nothing. I normally wear a merino wool base layer and am happy with the layering concept from experience hill walking and fishing so with that in mind maybe the smock is the way to go... In which case I just have to decide between the Rivers West and the Ridgeline...