Really pleased with my new 1.9l d'max. Bought it for a number of reasons but the main pluses that did it for me were:
1. No Ad-blue
2. Under the weight limit for 70 on A roads
3. 3.5 ton towing capacity (though i VERY rarely need this) with a lot of the others if you pull the full 3500kg you only have about 200kg for canopy, extras and passengers, let alone anything in the back.
4. economy is pretty good if you have a long way to go and aren't towing.
Its my first pick-up so nothing really to compare it against apart from an old Landcruiser 4.5 pickup which aren't available in this country anyway.
The only niggles I have with it are that first gear is ridiculously low, but i would only really use it pulling away on a hill or towing so it isn't that much of an inconvenience and that the interior is a bit basic, but i guess basic is good it you are going to cover it in mud anyway.
I think the 1.9 gets a lot of flack, a bit unfairly IMO. Unless you are towing 3.5t around the whole time, you aren't going to notice the 10% drop in torque. You might just have to run it a gear lower to keep it moving.