Why Some Meat Tastes Gamey

maximus otter

Well-Known Member
The term ‘gamey’ often feels infuriatingly imprecise. It is somehow both positive and pejorative, used in one breath to describe unconventional meats at high-end restaurantsand in another to decry an unpalatable or off dish. People can’t seem to agree what types of meat qualify as gamey, or even how to define the flavor.

are-deer-venison-same-thing.jpg


Gamey is a catchall term. Originally, it referred to the unique characteristics of wild, hunted animals, which are already extremely diverse. But it now describes meat that is especially tough, lean, grassy, earthy, nutty, sour, metallic, or generally pungent. At its broadest, it covers any texture or flavor that isn’t common in a food system, which for most [people] means anything other than the tender, factory-farmed beef, pork, and poultry.

What does ‘gamey’ really mean?​

“In relatively simple terms, gamey-ness is most related to the intensity of the red color of meat,” Chris Kerth, a professor of meat science at Texas A&M University, tells Popular Science.

The more an animal uses a part of its body, he explains, the more red muscle

fiber it develops to supply it with blood and generate power. So the darker the hue, the more of a gamey, “somewhat metallic or bloody-serumy flavor,” you’re going to get in the meat.

What causes gaminess​

Heavy muscle use also leads to lean and tough meat, which some may describe as gamey.

Even the reddest industrially farmed meat, like “bright cherry red” beef, won’t taste gamey to most people, “not because of the color of the meat, but because of the mostly grain diet” we feed livestock.

“Wild animals, and farm animals allowed to forage without being fed grain, will produce meat that has a different fatty acid profile,” Kerth explains. Usually, wild animals’ varied diets create a healthy mix of unsaturated fats in their tissue. When cooked, Gagaoua adds, these fats break down to “produce flavors described as tallowy, grassy, or fishy”—the sort of flavors you might associate with pasture-grazed mutton or an old wild goose.

What’s more, aromatic compounds (the chemical building blocks of smells) in the foods animals eat often make it through digestion and into fat deposits. Those compounds impart subtle flavors to the animal’s meat, reflecting what it ate throughout its life.

Likewise, we know that both long-term stress and moments of acute fear right before an animal is killed can have a range of effects on meat tenderness and taste.


maximus otter
 
This would be my understanding of 'gamey', too - the 'high' flavour one used to get from (too-?)long-hung game. Also so-called ,haut gôut', in French - to make a gastronomic virtue of the in pre-refrigeration days less-avoidable over-ripe feathered and furred game.
 
Gameyness has no single meaning. For example a hung pheasant will be gamey from both decay and gut taint, a deer can be gamey due to gut taint, a rutting stag or a boar can be gamey due to the hormones in the meat or gut tainting and poor handling or all of the above.
 
Interesting. Rutty is a very specific taste (more of a smell in my experience) that’s different to the livery taste of blood in the meat, and different to a low-level gaminess that I sometimes get. Also having raised pasture fed mutton I do recognise a fishiness noticeable in the fat. I can’t say I’ve ever noticed this in deer, but then I’ve never shot deer with much fat on.
 
I was once asked by a local village butcher (who really knew his stuff), how well hung I wanted a bit of stewing venison...... "Turn off the chiller light, and I'll have the bit that glows...."
He came out with what looked like a large piece of anthracite, and man, did that smell "gamey"! It nearly emptied the shop, and even I was thinking the game must have been over for quite some time.
The surface was like a thin black leather coat, but when cut, the inside was soft and pink, almost like lambs liver.
After the usual braising in a slow oven with half a bottle of burgundy, veggies etc, the taste was absolutely sublime...
Chacun à son goût....

D.
 
Its a euphemism for gone off meat that will at best be an unpleasant culinary experience and at worst a day spent in the bathroom (country folk) or intensive care (townies)
Exactly. A friend of mine, a GP, of all people, wishing to 'create an impression' amongst his peers, by throwing a dinner party, obtained some grouse, in August. I visited him to discover hanging in his garage, a number of said grouse. They were shot @ ten days earlier. Its August, its 20 degrees ! Gamey (off) was the distinct 'aroma' coming from them. I told him to bin them. NO !, apparently they had to be like that for the particular 'delights' he was preparing for the 'do'. I said "You'll give them all food poisoning" ! "No I won't, I know 'exactly what I'm doing".
So, the dinner party was thrown. He did create an impression, not the one intended mind, the whole damned lot of them down with food poisoning. A number of them hospitalised, too.
 
As with most things, it’s okay in moderation. Hanging that pheasant properly over a weekend can enhance flavour. And let’s remember how hanging beef for 28 days is certainly desirable. And what about those ancient hams that hang from the ceilings in some shops a slice of which tastes divine.

But to leave meat of any description knocking about with the innards intact until it’s an eat all you can restaurant for maggots and other creepy crawlies isn’t for me. Liken it to salt. A sprinkle enhances food. Too much just ruins it.
 
My late grandmother told me that her grandmother was a cook in a big house. Pheasants were hung in a game room/ cellar and when they fell off their heads they were ready to be cooked.!
The thought of it makes me shudder.
D
 
My late grandmother told me that her grandmother was a cook in a big house. Pheasants were hung in a game room/ cellar and when they fell off their heads they were ready to be cooked.!
The thought of it makes me shudder.
D
Yup
I've seen that. They're ready when the maggots start dropping on the floor and the head comes off easy.
🤮
 
As with most things, it’s okay in moderation. Hanging that pheasant properly over a weekend can enhance flavour. And let’s remember how hanging beef for 28 days is certainly desirable. And what about those ancient hams that hang from the ceilings in some shops a slice of which tastes divine.

But to leave meat of any description knocking about with the innards intact until it’s an eat all you can restaurant for maggots and other creepy crawlies isn’t for me. Liken it to salt. A sprinkle enhances food. Too much just ruins it.
beef 28 days in a chiller is brilliant and as for the hams the salting and smoking prevents bacterial activity , as does drying such as with biltong.
 
Yup
I've seen that. They're ready when the maggots start dropping on the floor and the head comes off easy.
🤮
My Granddad used to say exactly this - “they need to hang until the maggots drop off”!🫣

Certainly not for me! I’m all for hanging to allow the muscle to start breaking down enzymes/tenderise but there is a limit!🤣
 
With deer I think it is often the metallic liver taste that puts people off which is very different to ageing type flavour
I think that's often a combo of poor bleeding and overcooking.


Interesting that the way I was taught to know the time to age seems uncommon now. I thought lots of people knew it but no one ever seems to have heard of it now

Take the average temperature and add it up each day.
30ish for small game and 40 for large game is about right

I.e. when ambient is 15C and you keep them in a garage then 2 or 3 days but if you have a 4C chiller then 10 days is fine for a deer.
 
I read a piece about dry aged beef some time ago and the guys doing it were experimenting on how long you could dry age for without it becoming dangerous to eat.
IIRC they got to 180 days and by that point they were having to cut off large chunks of mouldy meat and fat.
Apparently the taste was ‘strong’ aka ‘an acquired taste’ aka disgusting!!

I guess you could say it was gamey!!

For me, gamey is any meat with a stronger aftertaste that typically comes from its redness - cwd is quite pale and not gamey at all but I tend to find red too strong a flavour with too much of an iron back taste.
 
For me, gamey is any meat with a stronger aftertaste that typically comes from its redness - cwd is quite pale and not gamey at all but I tend to find red too strong a flavour with too much of an iron back taste.
I have heard many refer to gamey as the iron taste many connect with liver.
I dont think i would describe it like that.

To me game is gamey, just as mutton tastes as mutton, game taste of game. Do we need to describe it more than that?

I find roe and red to be gameyer than say fallow or moose.
I think much comes down to carcass handling and cooking. You can certainly enhance the gamey taste through cooking, also to unpleasant levels in some cases.
Just as with mutton, you can make the taste (some say it tastes wooly?) unpleasnt and overpowering by wrongful handling during butchering.

Some old recipes cooks woodcock without removing the innards...
I reckon that would make it taste quite gamey.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top