Bone saw recommendations?
- Thread starter Rod&Gun
- Start date
I use a normal fine tooth wood saw . It works perfect
Are you aware that there's a search function mate? This has been done to death numerous times!
DIY, go to screwfix/tool station, buy a pack of reciprocating saw blades, fine toothed. 6" length of 13 mm copper pipe, gently flatten 20 mm of end, insert blade and then crimp in vice. One home made bone saw. You could tart up the handle if you wish. Dish washer safe and costs about £2 max so no issue if you loose it.
D
D
For carrying on the belt I have a Silky "Pocketboy 130" folding pull-saw with the fine serration blade (from memory it is 17tpi or 20t/30mm).
I bought it on a whim and to be honest I am hugely impressed with it. For a field gralloch is it absolutely perfect, it goes through the aitch-bone with ease and will open the chest of a roe with just a few strokes. It folds to a compact "pocket" size (as the name would indicate), it is easily cleaned and shows no effects from getting rattled through the dishwasher. Blades are easily replaced when necessary.
All in all I am rather impressed with it.
I bought it on a whim and to be honest I am hugely impressed with it. For a field gralloch is it absolutely perfect, it goes through the aitch-bone with ease and will open the chest of a roe with just a few strokes. It folds to a compact "pocket" size (as the name would indicate), it is easily cleaned and shows no effects from getting rattled through the dishwasher. Blades are easily replaced when necessary.
All in all I am rather impressed with it.
Silky Pocketboy 130-10 medium, black 340-13
Silky Pocketboy 130-10 medium, black 340-13: Compact folding hand saw with medium serration. Blade length: 13 cm NL
uk.knivesandtools.eu
Is this the same model as yours? I'm looking for a field-use bone saw but the one on the link above looks far too coarse to be good for going through bones. Wonder if they have multiple tpi options
I was shown an Aitch bone trick by a buddy / fellow stalker, if you look at the face of this bone there are two distinct notches, The point of the blade is put in the largest notch, given a smart back hand strike, then a twist & the pelvic bone is split in two, think this is the same action that puts cows down when doing the splits on a sh***y yard.
Silky Pocketboy 130-10 medium, black 340-13
Silky Pocketboy 130-10 medium, black 340-13: Compact folding hand saw with medium serration. Blade length: 13 cm NL
Is this the same model as yours? I'm looking for a field-use bone saw but the one on the link above looks far too coarse to be good for going through bones. Wonder if they have multiple tpi options
They most certainly do have various "coarseness" options mate, I reckon that the medium will be far too vicious. You want the fine blade, it will either be rated at 20 teeth per 30mm or 17tpi.
Silky Pocketboy Folding Saw - 130mm / fine teeth
Silky PocketBoy
The Pocketboy is available in 3 teeth configurations (8, 10 and 20 teeth per 30mm) and 2 lengths (130mm and 170mm). Each Pocketboy has a colour-coded handle associated with the teeth configuration. Red - 8 Teeth Per 30mm - Large teethBlack - 10 Teeth Per 30mm - Medium teethBlue - 20 Teeth Per...
Mine has a blue handle, but according to those links above the fine option is now yellow handled? Either way, I do believe it is a belter of a saw.
Silky saws are amazing, but watch your fingers!
Silkys are great, and worth it for professional applications but what I use in an amateur way is I think it is nearly as good, having compared them side-by side with my friend's Silky (she is a Woodland Trust volunteer), seemingly comparable quality as far as I could see, slightly shorter, 120mm long, half the price (i.e. about the same as a basic Mora knife), and a varied selection of replacement blades available. Blades also a fraction of the price of Silky.
Actually a complete saw for less than the price of a Silky blade.
The finer toothed "dry wood" and "plastic pipe" blades would be better suited to bone, but you can actually still hack away with the supplied blade, if all your trying to do is quickly split the ribcage for a full gralloch without risking dinging up a decent knife.
Also is ideal for other duties, gardening, tidying up vegetation that is over-growing your high seat, etc.
The blades are thin, Japanese profile to cut on "the pull", not "the push".
For a bit less than the price of a Silky you could have one of these with the standard 10 tpi general purpose greenwood pruning and coarse sawing blade, and say the 22 tpi "plastic pipe" one for bone. I just have the standard one, general purpose blade, and find it very useful, and even though only £15 I can't fault it.
Well, that's my suggestion.
www.axminster.co.uk
www.axminster.co.uk
Actually a complete saw for less than the price of a Silky blade.
The finer toothed "dry wood" and "plastic pipe" blades would be better suited to bone, but you can actually still hack away with the supplied blade, if all your trying to do is quickly split the ribcage for a full gralloch without risking dinging up a decent knife.
Also is ideal for other duties, gardening, tidying up vegetation that is over-growing your high seat, etc.
The blades are thin, Japanese profile to cut on "the pull", not "the push".
For a bit less than the price of a Silky you could have one of these with the standard 10 tpi general purpose greenwood pruning and coarse sawing blade, and say the 22 tpi "plastic pipe" one for bone. I just have the standard one, general purpose blade, and find it very useful, and even though only £15 I can't fault it.
Well, that's my suggestion.
Ishinoko Japanese Folding Pocket Saw - 120mm
This small folding saw fits in your pocket, easily to hand no matter where you are. This saw is incredibly handy in o many different trades, pastimes and outdoor pursuits. The steel handle is fitted with a comfortable and tough non-slip grip. There are...
www.axminster.co.uk
Blades for Ishinoko Japanese Folding Pocket Saw - 120mm
These blades feature impulse-hardened cutting edges for maximum durability. The toothed blades have Japanese style teeth giving a fast, smooth action and leaving a clean result. The range includes blades for cutting insulation or cardboard and one for...
www.axminster.co.uk
Silkys are great, and worth it for professional applications but what I use in an amateur way is I think it is nearly as good, having compared them side-by side with my friend's Silky (she is a Woodland Trust volunteer), seemingly comparable quality as far as I could see, slightly shorter, 120mm long, half the price (i.e. about the same as a basic Mora knife), and a varied selection of replacement blades available. Blades also a fraction of the price of Silky.
Actually a complete saw for less than the price of a Silky blade.
The finer toothed "dry wood" and "plastic pipe" blades would be better suited to bone, but you can actually still hack away with the supplied blade, if all your trying to do is quickly split the ribcage for a full gralloch without risking dinging up a decent knife.
Also is ideal for other duties, gardening, tidying up vegetation that is over-growing your high seat, etc.
The blades are thin, Japanese profile to cut on "the pull", not "the push".
For a bit less than the price of a Silky you could have one of these with the standard 10 tpi general purpose greenwood pruning and coarse sawing blade, and say the 22 tpi "plastic pipe" one for bone. I just have the standard one, general purpose blade, and find it very useful, and even though only £15 I can't fault it.
Well, that's my suggestion.
Ishinoko Japanese Folding Pocket Saw - 120mm
This small folding saw fits in your pocket, easily to hand no matter where you are. This saw is incredibly handy in o many different trades, pastimes and outdoor pursuits. The steel handle is fitted with a comfortable and tough non-slip grip. There are...
Blades for Ishinoko Japanese Folding Pocket Saw - 120mm
These blades feature impulse-hardened cutting edges for maximum durability. The toothed blades have Japanese style teeth giving a fast, smooth action and leaving a clean result. The range includes blades for cutting insulation or cardboard and one for...
I have one, great tool for the price!
cookingfat
Well-Known Member
My old DS bone saw was very very good. The new one I have is rubbish! Could be a one off. Has anybody bought one lately?
Hunterjohnb
Well-Known Member
Have had a Gerber switch blade saw for many years and no complaints. New blades are easily purchased. It comes with a carry pouch for your belt.
TH4
Well-Known Member
Friend bought one a couple of months ago and it is fine. What was the problem with your one ?
paulbshooting
Well-Known Member
Castrom saw - they do a short and long version. I carry the long to cover all my deer needs and its done plenty of breast bones on deer with no issues. Orange handle so not lost it yet and easy to clean. T handle allows easy grip and use.
I started with a cheap bushwear one which failed. Buy quality once!
I started with a cheap bushwear one which failed. Buy quality once!
Similar threads
