landkeeper
Well-Known Member
i wonder is he 
No crime to want to protect his child and family, the usual unhappy lot seeking his head on a plate, they don't realise the public aren't now quite so convinced of the strategy in any event, it'll be good to see how the left try to place blame for the economic ramifications a few months hence on the shrill message they're so desperately clinging on to and highlighting here and now.
The best minds are to be found outwith politics on this one, the EU question and most, to be honest. Profs Geisecke and his protege Tegnal seem to know the score, Prof Sunetra Gupta's reading of the situation, increasingly shown to be the correct one was posited at the time, but was sidelined by Ferguson's doomsday scenario.No crime? He flouted the rule that he helped devise and impose on others surely? What about all those others who also wanted to protect their families by leaving cities to go to their second homes in less densely populated areas of the country.
It is only a political issue because he and Boris chose to make it one...why they did not get the best minds from all parties together to counter the national threat I don't know. But then as usual I am out of step...I thought that following the result of the National Referendum on the EU that too should have been tackled by a cross party negotiating team to devise the best deal in the interests of the country and not make it a confrontational party political issue guided by unelected bureaucrats like Cummings and all about what is good for them.
I am surprised that no mention has been made of resignation from Boris who went off to his country home at Chequers during Lockdown...what with the Scots and the UK medical advisors falling on their swords for their similar broaches of the lockdown...and now Dominic Cummings ignoring it, travelling from London at the height of its infection, while they were showing symptoms, to an area at the time with few cases....unbelievable.
Why apologise for him and pour scorn on his critics?
Alan

The best minds are to be found outwith politics on this one, the EU question and most, to be honest. Profs Geisecke and his protege Tegnal seem to know the score, Prof Sunetra Gupta's reading of the situation, increasingly shown to be the correct one was posited at the time, but was sidelined by Ferguson's doomsday scenario.
We are where we are today, some of us just see things a bit more independently of the preferred groupthink, and, as with the outcome of the virus, the 'second wave' etc, time will tell, and the worse than useless opposition will try to blame the economic catastrophe that is to unfold on the policies they themselves are right now espousing.
Cummings is probably intelligent enough to make his own mind up without having to slavishly follow clearly daft guidelines...
the bit that ****es me off is we were all told to stay away from parents with our kids ! im sure there were are will be 100s of families who would have loved some help if one or other parent got sick but no we all had to stay home and stay awayThe basis of transmission through proximity and association are fairly clear...stay away from other people and things they have recently breathed over and handled...Cummings drove across the country with a person showing symptoms, to an area where there was little infection at the time, presumably sharing bugs at every service station stop on the way?
So you justify anybody's flouting of the "Stay at Home, Save the NHS, Save lives" mantra based on their IQ?
Whether you agree or disagree with the fairly international Lockdown response to the virus...surely Cummings is also intelligent enough to know that there might be repercussions when he chose not to follow (even in spirit) the rules imposed on others, which were laid down by the PM / government to whom he is chief adviser?
Alan
Be fair - it was his mother’s birthday party! Perhaps being observed dancing in her back garden by a neighbour didn’t help?the bit that ****es me off is we were all told to stay away from parents with our kids ! im sure there were are will be 100s of families who would have loved some help if one or other parent got sick but no we all had to stay home and stay away
Assuming one is sufficiently intelligent to recognise that two parties independently isolating are unable to pass the virus on to one another after the initial safe quarantine time has been exceeded, the advice is somewhat otiose, no? So if you and your kinfolk holed up elsewhere have been careful, there's no reason not to go and give them a hug.
Trouble is, many are insufficently intelligent, and/or very possibly insufficiently careful.
Be fair - it was his mother’s birthday party! Perhaps being observed dancing in her back garden by a neighbour didn’t help?
I am impressed though by the ‘protective ring’ the Tories are building around him..... second time lucky, I suppose.
"So what you're saying is.."The basis of transmission through proximity and association are fairly clear...stay away from other people and things they have recently breathed over and handled...Cummings drove across the country with a person showing symptoms, to an area where there was little infection at the time, presumably sharing bugs at every service station stop on the way?
So you justify anybody's flouting of the "Stay at Home, Save the NHS, Save lives" mantra based on their IQ?
Whether as an independent thinker, you agree or disagree with the fairly international Lockdown response to the virus...surely Cummings is also intelligent enough to know that there might be repercussions when he chose not to follow (even in spirit) the rules imposed on others, which were laid down by the PM / government to whom he is chief adviser?
Alan


"So what you're saying is.."KathyAlan, I think we're both sufficiently intelligent not to try to put words in the mouths of others, or attempt to twist the meanings.