I don’t see it in quite the same way
First of all, both she and the other guide were trails guides which means that they have both completed extensive training culminating in the “special Knowledge and Skills DG course - a very thorough program that must be completed before being allowed to conduct walking safaris with tourists in DG areas
This and earlier courses would have exposed trainees to exactly this kind of scenario
They all are tested on their ability to conduct VDG assessments- which are assessments on approaching and viewing DG
The choice of pushing through thick bush in a known buff area was (dependent on context) perhaps unwise, however that would not have been her decision as she was back up and not in charge of the walk
This issue of picking up a camp rifle that you are unfamiliar with is a common one - and is dealt with extensively during FGASA guide training
All guides are trained to run their ammo through the rifle prior to leaving camp (known as “chamber rounds drill”)) as it well known (and documented) that people pick up the wrong ammo in haste and also that ammo can deform as a result of being dropped or exposed to previous recoil
This she clearly did not do and it nearly resulted in loss of life - so that was an error of judgment
DG rifles are very often the cause of failing the annual shooting tests as many rifle actions fail under the fast chambering / fast reloads that guides are required to show competency in
I’ve got rid of 2 of my Mauser 98 DG rifles for just that reason
The idea that not shooting saved the day is a bit fanciful- if this video features in future guides courses I suspect the instructors will take that idea to task
As for head angle of the buff - these scenarios are all covered extensively in training
Trainee guides dissect buff and ele heads in order to get a clear understanding of brain position relative to external features at all angles
In summary I would suggest that errors were made but neither she nor her lead guide would have been inexperienced
They were damn lucky - must do better
PS - A lot of guides are not hunters and do not put the practice in with their firearms that they should- this too is well known
First of all, both she and the other guide were trails guides which means that they have both completed extensive training culminating in the “special Knowledge and Skills DG course - a very thorough program that must be completed before being allowed to conduct walking safaris with tourists in DG areas
This and earlier courses would have exposed trainees to exactly this kind of scenario
They all are tested on their ability to conduct VDG assessments- which are assessments on approaching and viewing DG
The choice of pushing through thick bush in a known buff area was (dependent on context) perhaps unwise, however that would not have been her decision as she was back up and not in charge of the walk
This issue of picking up a camp rifle that you are unfamiliar with is a common one - and is dealt with extensively during FGASA guide training
All guides are trained to run their ammo through the rifle prior to leaving camp (known as “chamber rounds drill”)) as it well known (and documented) that people pick up the wrong ammo in haste and also that ammo can deform as a result of being dropped or exposed to previous recoil
This she clearly did not do and it nearly resulted in loss of life - so that was an error of judgment
DG rifles are very often the cause of failing the annual shooting tests as many rifle actions fail under the fast chambering / fast reloads that guides are required to show competency in
I’ve got rid of 2 of my Mauser 98 DG rifles for just that reason
The idea that not shooting saved the day is a bit fanciful- if this video features in future guides courses I suspect the instructors will take that idea to task
As for head angle of the buff - these scenarios are all covered extensively in training
Trainee guides dissect buff and ele heads in order to get a clear understanding of brain position relative to external features at all angles
In summary I would suggest that errors were made but neither she nor her lead guide would have been inexperienced
They were damn lucky - must do better
PS - A lot of guides are not hunters and do not put the practice in with their firearms that they should- this too is well known
Last edited: