BARF Diet for 4 years now
Feeding your dog has to fit in with your life style, once our last 2 dogs passed away at the age of 13, we replaced with 3 pups; 2 bitches and one dog. From 8 weeks old and on, (4 years now) we have been feeding the BARF diet, This is a more difficult way of feeding than the simple "dry food" Eukanuba or Science plan method and all 3 are doing well on the barf diet but truthfully I have found in the 4 years there is no difference between feeding the BARF diet or sticking to the dry food (as long as it is a quality dry food).
Our first 2 dogs (which past away at age of 13 years) were strong large dogs, the boy was 14 stone and our girl a good 10 stone and they were started on Eukanuba as pups and this altered through the years with Science Plan and other HIGH quality dry foods, often supplemented with raw meat.
Our 3 replacement pups were on the BARF diet since day one, chicken wings, legs, breasts as pups along with pilchards, tuna, raw fish & minced tripe
They now regularly feed on Heart & tripe as main diet as well as cut up beef, chicken, fish etc as well as veg especially carrots & turnip. If the catch rabbit or any other type of game its also there right to enjoy the feeding of it.
All 3 have grown up fit & healthy, strong boned & excellent coats but they are not as strong or as large as the last two we had, this is absolutely nothing to do with the diet but down to the kennel club encouraging breeders to breed a smaller dog which is totally wrong for the breed of dog I own.
I better say the working dogs we have are not for retrieving and if we tried that they would think they had gone to heaven for the day and would eat every piece of game shot down. Our dogs are Alaskan Malamutes trained to pull sledges and they are a difficult breed to handle but once trained (as much as you can train a malamute) they are amazing dogs
So as for diet; in my opinion both dry food & barf (raw) food diets work equally as well but it is very difficult if not impossible to try and convert a raw food dog onto dry food once the diet is established (Beware).
The BARF diet takes much more planning and time and equally as expensive as good quality dry food such as Eukanuba , science plan, Arden grange etc (you also need a separate freezer).
All our pups from litters are brought up on dry food as this is the easier way for people taking on a "first malamute" as malamutes are a bit more difficult than the average dog to handle and rear.
.