I bought a pair of Harkila for the first time last year because of their reputation , up until then I had used some Jack Pyke ones. I must say I was a bit disappointed as only after a few times use whilst beating I noticed the stitching had come loose but after contacting the seller ( Philip Morris) they sent me a new pair with no quibble which seems so far ok with regards to stitching }. I must say though they are a very comfortable boot to wear all day, keeping my feet dry and warm . As I wanted a wide fit I had to go for a size bigger especially if you are going to wear thick socks. I have been using the second pair for over a year now and they seem fine.