Invincible deer?

Our passion is your passion... stalk with us!
I've heard a lot of people using vmax on roe recently It seems too preform really well Its less damaging externally than the regular hunting ammunition whilst absolutely smashing the internals.

I'm not particularly bothered just another weird case, I would of been disappointed if It was an obvious gut shot (and I was in the moment, I assumed) but on inspection, I cant really see an error on my end bit back sure, but nothing that should of kept it on its feet.

I wonder if adrenaline Is too play a bit I spotted them stopped whilst on quads about 250y out and when I drove down and popped over the hill they were on the move, I feel like they caught my wind a smidge rather than outright seeing me, thermals were pushing it everywhere. 🤔
 
Sol said:
I've heard a lot of people using vmax on roe recently It seems too preform really well Its less damaging externally than the regular hunting ammunition whilst absolutely smashing the internals.

I'm not particularly bothered just another weird case, I would of been disappointed if It was an obvious gut shot (and I was in the moment, I assumed) but on inspection, I cant really see an error on my end bit back sure, but nothing that should of kept it on its feet.

I wonder if adrenaline Is too play a bit I spotted them stopped whilst on quads about 250y out and when I drove down and popped over the hill they were on the move, I feel like they caught my wind a smidge rather than outright seeing me, thermals were pushing it everywhere. 🤔
Click to expand...
Atleast you managed a follow up and it died. Never a nice feeling seeing them living longer than expected after you shoot them.
 
Sol said:
Not sure how this roe managed too be on its feet for over 5 minutes with not a single reaction too being hut, ended up having too be shot again obviously not sure what ones mine, and what Is his but the exit on the other side (he took quartering, exited at the neck) Is pretty small with very minimal blood on the coat, tighter too the shoulder too so lungs being damaged shouldn't of been an issue. 🤔

no green spilt or anything both shots entirely within the diaphragm, another friend suggested the bullet pencilled through? pretty unusual for .222

I've had higher shots (if mine Is left) take a little longer expiry as gravity Isn't in your favour but even those have been within 45 seconds with obvious reactions too being hut, I've never had one be on its feet for so long looking around alert like nothing happened.

View attachment 476298
Click to expand...
Any pictures of the inside?
 
Sol said:
I've heard a lot of people using vmax on roe recently It seems too preform really well Its less damaging externally than the regular hunting ammunition whilst absolutely smashing the internals.

I'm not particularly bothered just another weird case, I would of been disappointed if It was an obvious gut shot (and I was in the moment, I assumed) but on inspection, I cant really see an error on my end bit back sure, but nothing that should of kept it on its feet.

I wonder if adrenaline Is too play a bit I spotted them stopped whilst on quads about 250y out and when I drove down and popped over the hill they were on the move, I feel like they caught my wind a smidge rather than outright seeing me, thermals were pushing it everywhere. 🤔
Click to expand...
Bullets can do weird and wonderful things. I recall a good few years ago sorting a 243 load with sierra 85g hollow points. We're talking ragged hole at 100 yards. Head shot a muntjac with them and found it blew up on impact. It didnt penetrate the skull and I ensured death with a knife. Tried them on fox and the same result. Got rid immediately after and went to 100g soft points. Worth noting I'm 99 percent sure everyone else recommended the 85g so was I just unlucky? Probably.

I've had ELD's impact broadside and exit through the haunch. It happens.

Petals from lead free tearing off and ending up in the back end after piercing the gralloch. Nothing is perfect but there certainly some are closer to perfect than others!
 
A fiend of mine @hannah123 shot a roebuck last summer. .308 180gr sp very little reaction.
It then started to slowly walk off. I thought lungs, it’ll soon go down.
Couldn’t get a follow up shot.
UKTDR came out first light next morning.
A 7/800 m track and we found it stone dead.
It had only just died. Eyes still bright etc.

Perfect placement but no expansion of the bullet.
 

Attachments

  • c1cc6a8f-7e38-4a61-9315-5d6c1e08766b.webp
    c1cc6a8f-7e38-4a61-9315-5d6c1e08766b.webp
    507 KB · Views: 43
  • Wow
Reactions: Sol
Many a barrel is different. Some rifling really can compromise a bullets jacket but the same bullets in a different barrel can keep it together just that micro second longer.

It's why some are happy to use a vmax and others are not.
There is no blanket rule but my rule is two holes are better than one.
 
nick100 said:
A fiend of mine @hannah123 shot a roebuck last summer. .308 180gr sp very little reaction.
It then started to slowly walk off. I thought lungs, it’ll soon go down.
Couldn’t get a follow up shot.
UKTDR came out first light next morning.
A 7/800 m track and we found it stone dead.
It had only just died. Eyes still bright etc.

Perfect placement but no expansion of the bullet.
Click to expand...
I feel like if we didnt dispatch it the outcome would of been similar It was very mobile I heavily expect no expansion, I cant say the gralloch had overly damaged lungs by any means but Its hard too tell with the second shot of course, the backside looked pretty undamaged though!
 
I was fairly sure it’d drop. We stalked on behind it. (Slow walking pace) it was in a field of beans expecting it to drop.

The only follow up available at any point was a Texas heart shot.

If my dog had been a few years younger he’d have soon pulled it down too.

Hind sight is a wonderful thing.
 
Yeah original shot was perfectly fine shooting upwards however It decided too loop back towards my mate towards houses, dont get me wrong there was a backstop with the angle a stone wall, then a wood behind it but regardless there's houses half a mile down that road Its just something I wouldn't attempt, not too mention the deer, me, and him where effectively a triangle me being at the tip If it decided too exit weird Its had the chance too come directly for him, just something I wouldn't do, no deer Is worth the risk no matter the scenario, the follow up a few minutes later was significantly safer. 👍

Its a shame! small buck wasn't really shot for the head more so for the meat but now Its got four holes in it wonder how bad Its going too be 🤦‍♀️
 
No deer has ever read the best practice manuals. Lung / behind the shoulder shots can always be tricky. There are not many major blood vessels - lots of little ones, but clotting system soon blocks those up. Bullet placement further forward has a much greater chance of severing major blood vessels which then quickly reduce blood pressure to a level where the animal looses consciousness. Doesn’t really matter whether you are using a .222 or a 7mm, shot placement is key.

I have had roe go 200m after taking a 7mm bullet through heart and lungs, show no sign of being hit but then saunter off and collapse stone dead.
 
Jh1986 said:
Shot a CWD at 200m with 150g copper Federal powershok. You heard the hit but the thing got up, trotted off 20m or so, then just stood. A second bullet had it on the deck but when I got there it was still breathing. Bullet through the lungs but still breathing.
Click to expand...
That’s typical cwd, pin shoulders sorts them out!
 
Sol said:
Deer are weird creatures sometimes!
Click to expand...
Not weird just they react to being shot as anything would, lung shoot a fox and it will take off just as fast if you missed it.
Shoot it front on in the bib and it will be far inclined to run, shoot it front on (pulled the shot and blow its leg off then it will take off..
 
Norfolk Deer Search said:
222 the OP

270 and the fallow - massive difference
Click to expand...
JH1986 posted this which I replied to
Shot a CWD at 200m with 150g copper Federal powershok. You heard the hit but the thing got up, trotted off 20m or so, then just stood. A second bullet had it on the deck but when I got there it was still breathing. Bullet through the lungs but still breathing.
 
Tim.243 said:
JH1986 posted this which I replied to
Shot a CWD at 200m with 150g copper Federal powershok. You heard the hit but the thing got up, trotted off 20m or so, then just stood. A second bullet had it on the deck but when I got there it was still breathing. Bullet through the lungs but still breathing.
Click to expand...
Factory copper and home loaded copper are 2 very different things!

Factory copper in my opinion is way too fast!

Pin shoulders sorts the problem- no front legs can’t go anywhere

For the record I’ve seen them shot with lead and run long distances too.
 
Sol said:
Deer are weird creatures sometimes!
Click to expand...
That sums it up perfectly.

My view is that if there is any doubt in your mind put a second shot in it. I shot a muntjac on a guided stalk...I knew the shot was good but for some reason the guide seemed a bit funny so a put a second shot into the muntjac....first shot smashed its heart to bits and the second rendered the front end of the carcass "not fit for more then dogfood". I did tell the guide the first shot was good...oh well "if in doubt".
 
Norfolk Deer Search said:
Factory copper and home loaded copper are 2 very different things!

Factory copper in my opinion is way too fast!

Pin shoulders sorts the problem- no front legs can’t go anywhere

For the record I’ve seen them shot with lead and run long distances too.
Click to expand...

Ever wondered if the reason you are having to pin shoulders is because your bullets arnt performing the best?
 
RCS Deer Management said:
Ever wondered if the reason you are having to pin shoulders is because your bullets arnt performing the best?
Click to expand...
I still use lead and don't have any issues with expansion, but agree with @Norfolk Deer Search on pinning front shoulders..
I always pin the front shoulders on all muntjac I shoot - I know they aren't going to run, and removes risk of green contamination as 90% of the time they are quartering away/towards you.

I think it is all down to individual scenarios, the estate we manage has a lot of footfall from dog walkers and guests, so I would rather lose some meat on the shoulder but have the animal drop on the spot with no risk of it running on. Boundaries are also an issue, as we don't have any access to surrounding land. In other areas you might elect for standard shot placement behind the shoulder, but as I said I think it is very scenario dependent.

Sandy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

I may have positioned myself behind a rifle in the wrong way until now
2 3 4
Replies
63
Views
4K
Scarpa
Scarpa
Button bucks.
Replies
2
Views
914
SOE
S
Daily Telegraph - ‘It's fight or flight... deer are not Disneyfied mini-humans’
Replies
11
Views
1K
375win
375win
Caliber increase, change shot placement or both?
2
Replies
35
Views
2K
25 Sharps
25 Sharps
Muntjac spleen and lung
Replies
7
Views
620
PEM406
PEM406
BRACES of Bristol - Sauer 100 XTA Stainless Package
Back
Top