Hi Brit. I do measure scope tubes - I have some 26mm diameter scopes as well as 1" & I match my rings carefully. My scope was a 30mm Swarovski not 1". It was on the rifle when I bought it (fitted by a competent gunsmith) I only saw the problem when I removed the scope after a couple of years. I had checked the screws were nipped up a couple of times & don't think I was too brutal.
There may possibly have been larger than ideal gaps at the split but IMHO the problem definitely was the differential clamping load leading to stress concentration on the bottom part of the scope by the small base segment of the rings.
A 30mm tube is more likely to get crushed than a 1" one.
Whatever the reason Apel rings are not my preferred choice now! The design is just wrong. I don't like springing the top strap over the scope tube & I don't fancy damaging another scope! The only scope I'd use Apel with would be made of steel. It's a pity because the Apel rings are very high quality build.
All this is why I really like the Optilock / Burris Signature style of rings.
Ian