enfieldspares
Well-Known Member
The really awful part is that this was predicted as early as the mid-1930s and nothing was done about it...the Vansittart Memorandum...which predicted that if the Britain failed to invest in proper defence resources that, if the Japanese attacked, that Singapore would fall. He wrote "We are incapable of checking japan in any way if she really means business". And of course we didn't. And after the Japanese attacked Malaya Churchill's ineptitude with Force-Z. It's supporting aircraft carrier couldn't continue with the Prince of Wales and the Repulse. Churchill's Admirals told him, bluntly, that if he sent them without this air cover that they would be detected and if detected they would be sunk. Not only did he ignore that but he then publicly announced he had sent them. Thus alerting the Japanese to search for, and that presence and try to detect and locate them. As a former First Sea Lord he should have known that their real value would have been to keep them secret to then strike without prior warning of their presence at the Japanese invasion vessels. The guns could, for the most part, face inland. But as they had almost exclusively armour piercing (anti ship) and not high explosive ammunition were useless against land targets.
And now Private Pike wants us to re-establish a Naval Base in Singapore? To do what? Fight the Chinese? We can't even stop illegal migrants in rubber dinghies landing sixty miles south of London. Yet Private Pike thinks we'll somehow do what, exactly, in relation to the Chinese. Fervid fantasy. He's clearly had one too many of his Mummy's rum babas. It's that and the brandy butter talking.
And now Private Pike wants us to re-establish a Naval Base in Singapore? To do what? Fight the Chinese? We can't even stop illegal migrants in rubber dinghies landing sixty miles south of London. Yet Private Pike thinks we'll somehow do what, exactly, in relation to the Chinese. Fervid fantasy. He's clearly had one too many of his Mummy's rum babas. It's that and the brandy butter talking.
Last edited: