MacNab Attempt - Isle of Harris

So a few folk might remember this thread from a while back: Good, inexpensive red stag - another fantastic offer for charity

Caorach was good enough to draw my attention to the auction and I was lucky enough to bid for and win the MacNab opportunity on the Amhuinnsuidhe Estate on the Isle of Harris (a salmon on the fly, a brace of grouse and a stag all in the same day). I'm just back and here's my write-up. Apologies in advance - it's a long one! But I've tried to insert a few photos to break it up and make it a bit more enjoyable to read. Grab a brew (or a glass of malt) and hopefully a few of you enjoy reading about the experience.

It seems like an age since the auction but eventually the time came and we headed north last week. The weather driving up through the highlands was filthy, and didn't really improve by the time we got to Ullapool. At least the rain eased off but it was blowing a hoolie! The 2 1/2hr ferry ride was a really rough one and lots of green faces and sick bags!

In the middle of the crossing the coastguard rescue helicopter came alongside for a bit of practice - amazing flying as they hovered alongside for a good 20 mins in force 7-8 winds!

untitled-3956.webp

We stayed in a self catering house towards the south of Harris and the estate were good enough to allow us to fish a bunch of their trout lochs for free. Some light tackle and some hard fighting little brownies made for a great evening or two.

My wife (7 1/2 months pregnant!) wetting a fly on one of the Borve Estate lochs.

1.webp


One of the Borve Estate lochs, looking back down to the coast
2.webp


Harris is truly beautiful - we didn't have the best of weather for photos, but the scenery is amazing:

4.webp

untitled-3976.webp

untitled-3982.webp

The food wasn't too shabby either:

FullSizeRender.webp


We even managed an hour or two off the rocks with a few feathers and had a enough mackerel for a rather good supper!

12.webp



The week seemed to fly by and before I knew it, it was MacNab day. The forecast was truly awful and for once they were bang on. I arrived at the castle and it was incredibly welcoming. There was a party staying at the castle and they all knew about me coming "you must be the chap trying for the macnab?" and there was a degree of excitement about me going out, which all added to the pressure!

Not my picture, but the castle is stunning:
top8.webp

Incidentally, the name of the castle apparently means river of the fairies...

Innes the Estate Manager showed me around, where to dump all my stuff and introduced me to the ghillies - the estate has 5. The was a "picnic room" where I could help myself to lunch; a great spread of cold meats, cheese, rolls, chocolate bars, drinks etc.

While I was sorting lunch, my ghillie tackled up my rod in the fishing room, before we loaded up the pickup with gear and headed off. We were going to be out all day so I had a mountain of kit! Rifle, shotgun, rod, boots, wellies, waders, binos, several jackets, fishing and shooting waistcoats, a couple of caps plus a few bits of dry clothing - all of which I'm glad I took!

The river system as it enters the sea right next to the castle:

14.webp

We started off after the salmon as apparently that's the hardest. We fished a couple of small pools on the river outside the castle. The water was deep, dark and brooding and it just looked "fishy"!

7.webp

Sure enough, 3rd cast and bang! I was into a fish. Was it?? Was it?? Nope, only a little sea trout or finnock. Still a nice fighting fish of about 3/4 of a lb.

We fished a couple more pools on the way up the river before heading up to the range for me to put a couple of rounds into the target. Sorry about the colours on this one - iPhone couldn't cope with the contrast between the bright sky (about the only patch of blue sky we saw all day) and the dark foreground:

6.webp


The range was a bit of a challenge as it was very exposed and there was a 30+ mph crosswind blowing. I pulled my first shot (but knew I had) then put two within 1/2", about an inch left (wind) and an inch high (which is where my rifle is zeroed). The ghillie was happy and off we went for a bit more fishing.

The range - no shelter and the wind is howling right to left:
8.webp


I fished one of the lochs up by the range, but still no luck with the fish, so the plan was to head to Loch Voshimid, but park up and walk in the last mile or so with the dog and shotgun in the hope of getting the grouse. The scenery in this area is really, really stunning with the huge Stron Scorst towering over the valley. Sadly the weather was deteriorating rapidly, with low cloud and heavy rain so not many decent pictures.

Stron Scorst is the lumpy bit of mountain in the middle of the picture and the Voshimid system is up the valley immediately to its left:
5.webp

The dog flushed a few grouse and I had a couple of half chances, but nothing straightforward. A few more I had to let go as they stayed low in the wind and no safe shot with the dog in the foreground. We got to the north shore of the loch and I'd fired 2 shots but no grouse in the bag.

I changed into waders and fished the north shore of the loch for an hour or so. The weather was getting worse - the wind picking up and frequent heavy, squally showers were piling in. Casting with a light rod and a couple of decent sized flies (as is the way up there) was hard going, but I had another couple of little sea trout and saw a fair few salmon moving so knew there was a good chance I was putting a fly over a salmon.

But no luck, so after an hour we decided to crack on and try and get the grouse and the stag. I swapped back to the shotgun we set off the mile or so back to the vehicle. We'd not gone 50yds when the dog was obviously onto something and sure enough, a grouse got up and a quick shot - one in the bag. Another 100yds, another grouse; this one a testing curler at a good range. It was hard hit and curled on the wind and dropped over the next hillock. The dog quickly picked it, and we were a third of the way through the challenge but time was marching on - about 1:30pm by now.

To be continued as I can only attach 15 pics per post...
 

Attachments

  • 13.webp
    13.webp
    395.5 KB · Views: 105
Last edited:
[FONT=&amp]So back to the car where I ditched some layers, swapped the shotgun for the rifle and up on the hill we went. The ground was seriously steep and rough and it was hard going, especially as the weather was getting worse and worse. I'm not unfit and I still found it really hard work. The rain was heavy and persistent, and the wind howling. Visibility was terrible and spotting ahead of us was pretty much impossible, as every time you lifted the binoculars they got soaked or misted up. Sorry, not many pics of this part as the weather was really, really grim! Even talking with the gillie was hard work at times.
[/FONT]

[FONT=&amp]Sron Scorst from the other side of the valley during a brief lull in the weather:
[/FONT]
9.webp
[FONT=&amp]
About halfway up the 600m climb from valley level - that's our pickup way down below:
[/FONT]
10.webp
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]We climbed ever upward and checked a couple of corries but no sign of deer, which tend to favour the high ground year round in this part of the world. Eventually we spotted a herd of hinds, but no stags, so we climbed yet higher to get around them and drop back down to where the ghillie thought there was a chance of some stags. [/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]We got a lucky break and the weather cleared for a brief period and we spotted another group of hinds below us, but this time with a stag. We stalked in but they were twitchy and knew something was up, so it was rifle out, load up and ready to to take the shot pretty quickly. We'd got to within about 130m, but they were well below us on the steep ground and there was a howling crosswind blowing. [/FONT][FONT=&amp]I had the ok to take the shot whenever I was ready but had to wait a few seconds until the stag stepped forward from behind a big tussock. He stopped clear broadside and I took the shot. [/FONT]

[FONT=&amp]I heard a good bullet strike and he took a few wobbly steps backwards before dropping and rolling downhill out of sight. I wasn't entirely convinced by the shot as I was worried I'd not compensated enough for the wind, so watched the area for a good while in case he got up again, but no sign of any movement. A good 5 minutes of lying in a wet bog, we decided he was down to stay! Phew, not the most comfortable shot I've ever taken, but I didn't notice in the heat of the moment.[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]We climbed, scrambled and slid down the steep hillside to find a stone dead 9 point stag. Once gralloched, the shot was a touch further back than I'd have preferred, but it did the job. [/FONT][FONT=&amp]Incidentally, a quick check later in a ballistic calculator suggested 4 inches of windage needed, even at 130m![/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
11.webp
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]He was an older stag, but still in velvet (in tatters at least) but with a group of hinds - an unusual combo at this time of year up here, so a good one to take. He wasn't big, but they only average 11 stone in this part of the world.[/FONT]

[FONT=&amp]The ghillie was pleased as it was an easy drag out. We basically had to get it to the far shore of the loch in the background of the photo above - and that's a long way away. If you look at the full size image you can just make out a decent sized fishing hut on the road between the two lochs and that gives a sense of scale! It looked like a horrible mile and a half over rough ground to me, but apparently that was an easy one for this estate!! Just as well we'd not shot him the other side of the ridge!! No ponies or argos up here, so it was all done by hand.[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]Anyway, it was about an hour and a half drag back to the track, then another couple of miles to walk back and collect the pickup. A quick change of clothes which was definitely worth doing. I was pretty sweaty after all the exertion of the steep stalk, and my goretex jacket was soaked from the outside and the inside - not a great starting point for standing waist deep in cold water in -2 degree windchill! I was soon warm and dry again and back in the waders with fly rod in hand trying for the final piece of the jigsaw. This time we tried Loch Scorst, right under the hugely impressive Sron Scorst.

By now, the wind was crazy, accompanied by regular heavy showers. I was on the sheltered shore of the loch, but the wind was still so strong you simply couldn't backcast as the line was blown forwards as soon as you picked it up off the water. I was thigh deep in water on a nice smooth shoreline, but there were times when I was getting buffeted around and had to brace myself so I didn't get blown over! The best I could manage was a roll cast or a single false cast across the wind. Despite the conditions, I had another couple of small sea trout and saw a lot of salmon moving. They just weren't taking though and I called it a day about 30 mins before dark. I could have fished on, but I'd had an amazing day and conditions were starting to get the better of me and it started to become unpleasant. I reckon I'd seen 20-30 salmon jumping during the day, so knew I had been putting a fly over fish, but they just weren't taking. Time to end on a high and head back for a large dram!![/FONT]

[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]So final tally for the day: 2 grouse, 1 stag and 5 sea trout but no MacNab.

It didn't matter though, the whole experience was just amazing and hard to put into words. I was thoroughly exhausted, we'd walked over 10 miles over some incredibly wild, rough and steep ground and I'd had my most memorable sporting day ever. [/FONT]

[FONT=&amp]
[/FONT]
[FONT=&amp]Thanks to Caorach for highlighting the auction in the first place, and all his advice since.[/FONT]

A final picture from the ferry on the way back to the mainland - very sad to be leaving heading home!
untitled-4046.webp
 
Last edited:
Thank you very much for sharing that adventure with us and well done! I feel cold and wet just from reading that.
 
Fantastic report and although you didn't quite manage the full Macnab there is no question that you had spectacular sport, when you are starting to walk after driving seven miles on a rough track from a remote single track road then you know it is real stalking! You'll have to go some to top that as a day out.

For what it is worth the salmon and sea trout fishing has been extremely difficult this year with anglers fishing hard for a week for a fish, when five fish in a day is in the more common run of things, so it was no disgrace not getting your salmon. Come back next year for one and try out a few more of our rivers and lochs, although the salmon isn't going so well I'm currently getting great sport at the brown trout and might have a plan for some sea trout later in the week.
 
Great write up of the best of sport, well done. I have had a few 'MacNearlys' myself over the years and enjoyed everyone of them as much as if I'd got the 'treble up.'

I had a great time shooting over pointers (snipe and grouse) the other end (Barvas on Lewis) and your post has reminded me to one day book a day on the stags down on Harris too, stunning scenery.
 
Thanks for taking the time to post the write up and the photo's - really set me up for the long run to the far North at the end of the week for my week tormenting Salmon and my annual stag - if my one good eye will allow! Had a MacNearly a few years ago, but the Grouse were too thin on the ground so just had to amuse myself by shouting "bang" at them!:-D
 
Great write up, thanks for sharing. Your next couple of trips are going to seem a bit tame after that.
 
I was gutted I missed this opportunity alas I was too late. After such a glowing report I will certainly seek my own attempt in the future. It truly sounds like a great day out.
 
A cracking write up and a pleasure to read ! shame the final goal wasn't achieved but still a great day even if very tiring
 
Thanks for putting su h a good effort and time into sharing that great day. Really enjoyed reading it . Not managed to stalk on Harris but have been and would love to give the McNabb a go myself.
 
Back
Top