Best round for Reds

A similar thread to this one here:


That was the first week I’d one on red stags with the .270 and it was flawless, putting 5 beauties down at some good ranges up on the hill. That spiker with you was only my 6th. After years using 20” .308s with 130gr TTSX on all reds I’ve taken previously, I think I’m a total convert now to the .270 for all fallow and reds.

Previous thread with loads:

 
7x57 every day of the week!!! It is low recoil, very versatile and efficient. For reds, I use 139 grains Hornady SSTs and if you reload, you have a whole world of possibilities.
 
Hi,

Have a 6.5 creedmoor for stalking but am considering a larger calibre for reds. Any suggestions?

what sort of reds ?

highland reds .243 is fine

great big fat lowland dollop reds .243 is also fine if you can shoot , personally i prefer 6.5cm which has flattened them out to 400m for me

oh yeah , 45/70 - 300rum - 308 all work as well
 
Last edited:
So, given you’ll have shot more reds than I will ever in my lifetime, what’s your view especially as you get to see so many others choice of calibre and rounds please?
I think it is not just impacted by choice of calibre/bullet, but the person behind the trigger.
I have, and still do use my .243 and 80g Barnes TTSX into the engine room of the red, is that the best solution for reds?, probably not, I mainly use my 6.5x55 Swede 120g Barnes TTSX, the last 3 reds I shot dropped on the spot, at ranges less than 200m.
I don't head shoot, and don't permit my clients too so will not suggest anything.

The calibre I did love was the 30-06 and 180g lead Nosler Partition, job done.

But of course, the good old .270 is a brilliant calibre, and coupled with an accurate stalker as yourself worked well with the 110g Barnes TTSX
 
I think it is not just impacted by choice of calibre/bullet, but the person behind the trigger.
I have, and still do use my .243 and 80g Barnes TTSX into the engine room of the red, is that the best solution for reds?, probably not, I mainly use my 6.5x55 Swede 120g Barnes TTSX, the last 3 reds I shot dropped on the spot, at ranges less than 200m.
I don't head shoot, and don't permit my clients too so will not suggest anything.

The calibre I did love was the 30-06 and 180g lead Nosler Partition, job done.

But of course, the good old .270 is a brilliant calibre, and coupled with an accurate stalker as yourself worked well with the 110g Barnes TTSX
Agree completely.

Similarly using the 80gr TTSX in .243 but as my Summer general stalking round for roe and muntjac - it may have also accounted for a few fallow 🤭
 
Why change the 6.5 you have?!?! A 140gr will drop a red at any sensible range in the same way a 270 will!

If you just want another gun and to use it as justification then fine, but a 6.5CM will do the job with authority.

If you want something bigger - go 30-06, it has one of the biggest range of bullet weights and performance is fantastic.

Regards,
Gixer
 
The best bullet for your 6.5 is a Barnes tTSX in a 100 or 120 grain . I generally prefer the 100 grain as i find shooting longer ranges it opens up better on longer shots, opening up the petals is more important than the higher 20 grain weight of the 120.
I use a 260 rem with 1-7.5 twist , Accuracy wise both are the same though a lighter bullet recoils less and this helps when you need to drop a few at a time ( marginal but it matters ) Only deer i have not shot with this set up is Fallow as i haven't shot fallow in over 20 years perhaps at a guess
 
The best bullet for your 6.5 is a Barnes tTSX in a 100 or 120 grain . I generally prefer the 100 grain as i find shooting longer ranges it opens up better on longer shots, opening up the petals is more important than the higher 20 grain weight of the 120.
I use a 260 rem with 1-7.5 twist , Accuracy wise both are the same though a lighter bullet recoils less and this helps when you need to drop a few at a time ( marginal but it matters ) Only deer i have not shot with this set up is Fallow as i haven't shot fallow in over 20 years perhaps at a guess
actually the best bullet performance wise would be a lead one
 
Factory only or will you hand load?

If factory, I’d limit your search to 308 or 30-06 (plus perhaps a magnum). I like the 270 but having had 2 and shot factory ammo over a chrono, a lot is only achieving 2,800 to 2,900fps with a 130gr. Couple that with the bullets having worse BCs than most 6.5s, there’s going to be minimal real world gain.

I’d say the same for most other non 30 cal/non magnum cartridges, the tendency of factory ammo to be a bit mellow could easily mean you’d have no real benefit over the Creed.

If hand loading, it’s a totally different ball game as you can wring full performance out of some good cartridges like the 270, 7x57 etc.

Edit - another consideration is just to try a different bullet. When I used a 270 I would hand load a 150gr partition (have a read of Nathan Fosters thoughts) and it was a spectacular killer on reds. If you’ve got a hard 140gr, you might find a 120gr going a bit quicker will make the difference. Reds aren’t that big compared to what some people hunt, so a bully built for tough North American or Scandinavian hunting is going to be a bit hard on a Red.
 
  • Like
Reactions: av1
Factory only or will you hand load?

If factory, I’d limit your search to 308 or 30-06 (plus perhaps a magnum). I like the 270 but having had 2 and shot factory ammo over a chrono, a lot is only achieving 2,800 to 2,900fps with a 130gr. Couple that with the bullets having worse BCs than most 6.5s, there’s going to be minimal real world gain.

I’d say the same for most other non 30 cal/non magnum cartridges, the tendency of factory ammo to be a bit mellow could easily mean you’d have no real benefit over the Creed.

If hand loading, it’s a totally different ball game as you can wring full performance out of some good cartridges like the 270, 7x57 etc.

Edit - another consideration is just to try a different bullet. When I used a 270 I would hand load a 150gr partition (have a read of Nathan Fosters thoughts) and it was a spectacular killer on reds. If you’ve got a hard 140gr, you might find a 120gr going a bit quicker will make the difference. Reds aren’t that big compared to what some people hunt, so a bully built for tough North American or Scandinavian hunting is going to be a bit hard on a Red.
factory mate, I have some 140g normapoints which I bought for reds but sadly none were around.
 
Lea McNally liked the 243, others the 270 - lots of calibres in-between. David Lloyd liked the 264.

A rifle that you like and can shoot well is a huge priority.
 
Thank you for your advice guys, in view of timescales in acquiring a variation in northants these days, I think I will stick with my sakos20 and hopefully the normapoints 140g will do the job with the reds.
 
Back
Top